100 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
John Schmeeckle's avatar

"Lies, damn lies and statistics."

American credit card debt -- a sure sign of consumer stress -- is at an all-time high: https://www.lendingtree.com/credit-cards/credit-card-debt-statistics/

Workforce participation continues to be flat -- it has never recovered to its pre-covid level:

https://www.bls.gov/charts/employment-situation/civilian-labor-force-participation-rate.htm

And Biden continues to spur on the global trend of de-dollarization of international trade, with his reckless and wasteful support of Ukraine's oppressive, undemocratic far-right thug regime.

Expand full comment
Talia Morris's avatar

Unlike Russia's democratic invasion of Ukaine, I suppose.

Expand full comment
Dutch Mike's avatar

John Sméagol is a pro-Putin trollski posting the same stuff over and over again. We’d best ignore him.

Expand full comment
Aurelie Catherine Cormier's avatar

Dutch Mike, couldn't agree more. Best to ignore these trolls.

Expand full comment
Marycat2021's avatar

I blocked him, but I can still see his comments.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 19, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Dutch Mike's avatar

It's definitely not a Dutch name, I can assure you; it's more likely German or maybe of Jewish descent. But to me he always seems like Sméagol who turned into a creature that lived in a cave under the Misty Mountains and was constantly repeating itself with his signature sound "gollum, gollum"... Everytime someone mentions Ukraine or Zelensky, he immediately comes crawling out of his cave stating that HCR spouts "baseless propaganda" and Biden is supporting "the right wing thug regime" in Kyiv... His postings echo standard pro-Putin talking points and are more than tiresome...

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

The origin of my name is in the Toggenburg, a mountain valley in St. Gallen canton, Switzerland. This subject actually came up on a different thread today:

https://heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/p/august-18-2023/comment/36767491

"Dutch Mike," AKA "Mike S.," is a bully who "grooms" others to be abusive.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 19, 2023Edited
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Dutch Mike's avatar

Thanks :) But I am curious about another thing: you said you are a teacher. Where do you teach, if I may ask?

Expand full comment
Jen Andrews's avatar

I don’t think he’s particularly bright. He goes to a topic most people don’t know much about and spouts nonsense like credit card debt is a sure sign of…whatever. Kind of a clever idiot. But not smart.

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

I agree with you Jen, but the Troll has "successfully" disrupted the thread today. Now he has a Co-Troll.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Bryan Sean McKown seems to be acting like a McCarthyist social monitor.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Jen Andrews,

Perhaps I didn't phrase my earlier comment clearly. Right now we have the highest level of credit card debt in history. This is a sure sign of distress among people with little to spare.

Expand full comment
Hugh Spencer's avatar

I suspect that John is a very orthodox leftist. So only Bernie is sufficiently within the acceptable window, as it were. Remember - "the perfect is the enemy of the good" Which means while we may object, we have to be grateful that we are not having to deal with Repub "wind back the clock"

But remember - "Nature bats last".

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Actually, I'm an old-school FDR/JFK Democrat. The Apollo Program acted as a "science driver" for the economy, returning far beyond what we invested in it.

(Among other things, it spurred the development of the personal computer, leading to the internet economy.)

FDR -- my grandmother's fourth cousin -- was passionately anti-colonialist. He forced the British to give up their empire, in exchange for help against the Nazis.

Expand full comment
Jon Margolis's avatar

That’s nonsense. FDR did little or nothing to end British colonialism.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Perhaps Jon Margolis has never heard of the Atlantic Charter:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantic_Charter

Expand full comment
D4N's avatar

🤡

Expand full comment
Bill Katz's avatar

How come you don’t display your real name?

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

Bill, his name is known to Substack Inc because of his multiple attacks on other Substack Inc Platforms.

Expand full comment
Marycat2021's avatar

Why should he? I don't.

Expand full comment
Bill Katz's avatar

I stand corrected. If your desire is to win an argument, you don’t get there by word terrorizing as you have done. Reading some of your missives, there are elements to legitimize but using “far right thugs” doesn’t win the day. When I have argued against popular issues, I have been fully castigated so I get it. Opinions are like Aholes. Everyone has one.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Bill Katz,

Your criticism of my phrase "far-right thugs" makes no sense UNLESS you assume that it is inaccurate.

You didn't ask me for a source, but here goes:

"Neo-Nazis and the Far Right Are On the March in Ukraine"

https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/neo-nazis-far-right-ukraine/

"Five years ago, Ukraine’s Maidan uprising ousted President Viktor Yanukovych, to the cheers and support of the West. Politicians and analysts in the United States and Europe not only celebrated the uprising as a triumph of democracy, but denied reports of Maidan’s ultranationalism, smearing those who warned about the dark side of the uprising as Moscow puppets and useful idiots. Freedom was on the march in Ukraine.

"Today, increasing reports of far-right violence, ultranationalism, and erosion of basic freedoms are giving the lie to the West’s initial euphoria. There are neo-Nazi pogroms against the Roma, rampant attacks on feminists and LGBT groups, book bans, and state-sponsored glorification of Nazi collaborators.

"These stories of Ukraine’s dark nationalism aren’t coming out of Moscow; they’re being filed by Western media, including US-funded Radio Free Europe (RFE); Jewish organizations such as the World Jewish Congress and the Simon Wiesenthal Center; and watchdogs like Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and Freedom House, which issued a joint report warning that Kiev is losing the monopoly on the use of force in the country as far-right gangs operate with impunity...."

I have presented the above quote around here repeatedly, and have met with a deafening silence, as if HCR's readers have been intimidated and/or morally corrupted.

What do you say?

Expand full comment
D4N's avatar

🤡

Expand full comment
D4N's avatar

🤡

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Putin, in Ukraine, is reclaiming "Novorossiya," the multi-ethnic, Russian-speaking half of Ukraine that was stapled together with little Ukraine by the new Soviet regime in 1921.

As a result of the Biden administration's approach to the Russia/Ukraine mess, the global trend toward de-dollarization -- threatening financial chaos in the USA -- has been accelerating:

https://money.usnews.com/investing/articles/de-dollarization-what-happens-if-the-dollar-loses-reserve-status

Keep up the good work, Joe; we're all going to pay for it.

Expand full comment
Mike S's avatar

Actually,

It was Reagan, and every Republican elected after that, who began the slow process of wrecking the dollar (which Biden has begun to rebuild).

Reagan took Jimmy Carter's balanced budget; in fact, Carter continued to paydown WWII and Vietnam debt (like all Presidents since WW II) while sponsoring a healthy economy. Debt was reduced under every post WWII president until Reagan.

Reagan, upon his election based on a vacuous, puffy red face and fake smiles, immediately cut taxes on the wealthy and massively ramped up government spending on his big military contractor donors.

At the end of Reagan's disastrous Presidency (in terms of the budget and the economy) the US had added no less than 6 Trillion dollars in debt (today's dollars), suffered through TWO recessions in 8 years, and had lost the respect of most of the world except for Great Britain where another nut, Margaret Thatcher was also running amok trying to destroy Britain's influence in the world (she successfully did, nobody pays any attention to anything that happens in Britain unless the Queen treats some black woman poorly, which, she did).

The seeds were planted for the dollar's reversal as the world's reserve currency during Reagan's failed Presidency, and, with every Republican after that, debt has SOARED.

After the mess that Trump made of (everything) including adding more massive debt, the world looked at the US as if it was a banana republic with some seriously dumb white guys in charge. It frightened the world. I mean, Trump in charge of the nukes?

Fortunately, Biden won the election and beat long time loser Trump.

Biden is turning the American ship, but, it is hard to to turn a ship that Republicans have tried to sink for 40 years.

Surprisingly, Biden is doing it. Kudo's for Biden.

You Putin employees/trolls getting paid peanuts to hand out BS Russian propaganda?

You guys are sad. But, you are funny with that fake stuff you guys post. I guess some Americans believe that stuff.

But, John, not on this reflector. Here? You are just a joke.

Expand full comment
JDinTX's avatar

His claiming to be an old time Dem is the biggest joke yet

Expand full comment
Laurie MacNeill Clancy's avatar

Thank you for this detailed retort.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

You fantasize that the economy under Carter was "healthy," with oil-price shocks and stagflation.

The process of "wrecking the dollar" -- going back to Reagan, as you say -- can be measured by yearly increases in the national debt.

Obama was almost as bad as Trump and Biden (with Trump's final year distorted by the covid crisis):

https://www.statista.com/statistics/187867/public-debt-of-the-united-states-since-1990/

Your statement that Biden "has begun to rebuild" the dollar is a barefaced lie.

Expand full comment
Bill Katz's avatar

And btw John, you have a way of deflecting. Mike spoke of Carter paying down the debt as all presidents did until Reagan. Then you went off about stagflation and the oil crises which by the way, had nothing to do with Carter. The Iraq Iranian war and the Iranian revolution caused the crises in 1979. But those of you who conveniently search for boogie men like you do. You would do well to be honest and unemotional in your arguments.

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

Bill, can I ask you respectfully not to engage the Troll despite your cogent facts?

Expand full comment
Judith Dyer's avatar

Yes, see his name and scroll away.

Expand full comment
Bill Katz's avatar

The massive tax reductions of 2017 try that on for size.

Expand full comment
Mike S's avatar

John,

Had we, the USA in cahoots with the British, NOT overthrown the duly democratically elected Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddegh in 1953 and instead built partnerships with the middle east based on the "rules based order" that Biden speaks of, there would have been no "oil crisis" in the early 70's PRIOR to Carter's election.

Of course, there WAS a crisis in 1979 when the brutal dictator the Shah of Iran fled to the United States and the USA pissed off millions of Iranians who wanted to hang the Shah because he murdered thousands of their relatives while "in power". If I had been Iranian I would have been PO'd too.

Was that Carter's fault? Perhaps. But, honestly, it was really some low life Republicans in the Eisenhower government that planned coup without Eisenhower even knowing about it.

Carter and the "oil crisis" did not overlap in time as your lie would indicate.

As for Obama, I completely agree, Obama went wild with debt after eight years of deregulation by Bush II resulted in a complete catastrophe in banking and collapse of the economy in the USA; on the level of a Calvin Coolidge (also a Republican) disaster.

Me? I would have left the Republican's collapsed economy completely ALONE to take 20 years to rebuild so people would REMEMBER what Republicans do when they are in power. Like, for example, stupid deregulation of derivatives which became mortgage back securities (legalized) under Bush II in 2001.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Yes, there was also an earlier oil crisis under Nixon.

My point was that the economy was NOT healthy under Carter.

Regarding Mossadegh, etc., Carter's Attorney General Ramsey Clark wrote that U.S. policy toward Iran and Iraq was to support the opposition, overthrow the government, support the new opposition, overthrow the new government, etc. See Chapter 1 of "The Fire This Time":

https://archive.org/details/firethistimeuswa00clar

Expand full comment
D4N's avatar

🤡

Expand full comment
Terry Mc Kenna's avatar

Eastern Europe has always been a mix of languages and cultures and over time the borders shifted. But speaking russian or german or polish or whatever does not make a country. Russia aspired to a great empire but really could not hold it. Putin's attack was unjust. Frankly had his army succeeded then we would not have been able to do anything, but the "russian speaking" part of Ukraine hates Russia as much as the ukrainian part.

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

Terry, you have been successfully trolled, been taken off Topic.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

p.s. Perhaps you already know that Moscow was the daughter of Kyiv: Russians and Ukrainians were the same people.

Expand full comment
Terry Mc Kenna's avatar

Sorry but all this is history. I grew up as the grandson of immigrants from the Russian Empire. The question is about now. Had Russia been better led then the war would have ended - but they were not better led. The Ukrainians themselves hate the Russians who invaded.

History is fun. But what do we do now? Well we defended Ukraine. After the collapse of the USSR, I thought it was a mistake to encircle Russia by Nato. But do you really think the Poles or Lithuanians did not want the protection of NATO? Russia was not threatened by NATO in any case. What Russia needs to economic reform They graduate lots of engineers but build little that the world wants. They graduate lots of doctors but they are not the world leader that one has a right to expect.

In any case Russia guessed that they would win quickly and the west would sit on the sideline. Instead Russia in now isolated and the Nato that was a tepid alliance is now serious.

Re "the same people" - my Jasaitis family cousins look as Russian as Yuri Gagarin. the notion of one people is just a romantic myth.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

I have some disagreements with your assessments, but no need to argue.

Speaking of now, here is my assessment:

Ukraine has a realistic chance for a peace settlement if Ukraine agrees to give up the entirity of the four districts that Russia annexed on paper. Otherwise, there are three plausible alternatives to choose from:

1. An extended stalemate as NATO continues endless support of Ukrainian forces that are dug into defensive positions.

2. NATO escalates, bringing the forces of NATO countries (perhaps initially Polish army units) into direct conflict with Russia in Ukraine. (Poland is already thinking of absorbing chunks of a disappearing Ukraine, especially eastern Galicia.)

3. Russia breaks through the current line of control as weary and depleted western countries cut back on their arms giveaways to Ukraine.

Expand full comment
Bill Katz's avatar

No to your negotiation. The only negotiation will be over Crimea since it belonged to Russia in 1953. But that’s it. If Russia wants to bleed to death, that’s their problem. I happen to believe that the West forced Russia into a paranoid response. NATO expended east. On the other hand, Russia made half hearted attempts at democracy and failed. They are a mess.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

It is my view that the West forced Russia into a survivalist response. Russia had already experienced the western-inflicted "shock therapy" genocide that killed off all the old people:

https://archive.org/details/AGenocideRussiaAndTheNewWorldOrder1999

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Terry Mc Kenna,

There are two separate issues here: How modern Ukraine came to be, and why Putin invaded.

Novorossiya ("New Russia") was conquered from the Tatar slave raiders in the 18th century. The area had been depopulated because of the threat of slave raiders, and Empress Catharine the Great invited people of all ethnic groups to settle in the new Russian territory, and of course the official language was Russian.

After Ukraine's Maidan Revolution in 2014, the Russia-friendly members of Ukraine’s parliament were terrorized into staying home, and the first law that the rump parliament passed was to ban the Russian language in government communication.

This was part of what led Crimea to embrace Russia, as well as helping bring on the civil war in the Donbass, which got "frozen" with the Minsk Agreements of 2014 and 2015, which were never implemented. (Zelensky initially moved toward doing that, but then he didn't. Long story there.)

Perhaps you will agree that it's worth knowing Putin's formal rationale for invading Ukraine, if only to refute it:

Putin said to the world that he was fulfilling a mutual defense treaty with the Donbass republics (because Ukraine was attacking).

Expand full comment
D4N's avatar

🤡

Expand full comment
Joyce's avatar

BLS shows an upward trend in employment- recovering from pandemic low but an upward trend not seen in the past decade. Recovery is hard work. Just ask Trump- he never made advancements in the economy.

Expand full comment
Bill Katz's avatar

Schmeeckle the Pickle what is the matter with you? I do hope your Russian troll farm suspends your pay for proposing half-baked ideas. You are not very convincing. One might consider that the Ukrainian revolution of 2013 had outside influences. Maybe but all revolutions do. It’s not a far right thug regime. Ukrainians fighting for their existence. And you are correct that the eastern parts are Russian-speaking meaning culturally Russian. But most of them now repudiate their Russian culture in the face of total destruction of their people by Russian thugs. So put that in your little pipe and smoke it.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

"Neo-Nazis and the Far Right Are On the March in Ukraine"

https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/neo-nazis-far-right-ukraine/

"Five years ago, Ukraine’s Maidan uprising ousted President Viktor Yanukovych, to the cheers and support of the West. Politicians and analysts in the United States and Europe not only celebrated the uprising as a triumph of democracy, but denied reports of Maidan’s ultranationalism, smearing those who warned about the dark side of the uprising as Moscow puppets and useful idiots. Freedom was on the march in Ukraine.

"Today, increasing reports of far-right violence, ultranationalism, and erosion of basic freedoms are giving the lie to the West’s initial euphoria. There are neo-Nazi pogroms against the Roma, rampant attacks on feminists and LGBT groups, book bans, and state-sponsored glorification of Nazi collaborators.

"These stories of Ukraine’s dark nationalism aren’t coming out of Moscow; they’re being filed by Western media, including US-funded Radio Free Europe (RFE); Jewish organizations such as the World Jewish Congress and the Simon Wiesenthal Center; and watchdogs like Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and Freedom House, which issued a joint report warning that Kiev is losing the monopoly on the use of force in the country as far-right gangs operate with impunity...."

I have presented the above quote around here repeatedly, and have met with a deafening silence, as if HCR's readers have been intimidated and/or morally corrupted.

Expand full comment
Paul Allopenna's avatar

I looked at the work participation chart you linked to and if you estimate the trend line from the time of Covid you will see a gradual increase in the participation rate, and if you start from Biden’s inauguration, there is a linear trend upward from 61.3% to 62.4%. It has not reached the level from just prior to Covid: 63.3%. The trend is upward and by my calculations approximately 55% of the loss in participation has been regained. As far I know there is no gold standard for economic recovery over time, but this seems like a positive trend.

I’m on a phone so don’t have access to analytic tools, but using a different source from yours: https://www.newyorkfed.org/microeconomics/hhdc you can see that the trend in upwards for both housing and non-housing debt from 2013 Q2 to 2022 Q4 with some to-early-to-tell signs that both trends are flattening somewhat. I’m pretty sure that this state of affairs would analytically struggle to point to Joe Biden as the cause.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Thank you for your response. The labor force participation rate has been flat since March: https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/labor-force-participation-rate

Expand full comment
Paul Allopenna's avatar

John,

I think there are a number of ways to analyze and discuss this so first let me say that you are correct that the labor participation rate has been flat since March. I also think it might be still too early to tell whether or not this is a change in the general trend since January 2021. I would suppose that if the current rate holds for X (some arbitrary) length of time then the general trend line would flatten and your point would have more confirmatory evidence.

However, in looking at The Bureau of Labor and Statistics site you can see that there are umpteen factors that can be analyzed and it is unclear to me (not being an economist) what factors meaningfully interact to give a ‘true’ picture of the economy. Also, no matter what statistics you apply, I don’t think that data alone can tell a meaningful story without having some theoretical framework to judge against.

With those grains of salt taken, I looked at the participation data from the start of Trump’s term until the appropriate quarter for comparison to Biden’s tenure thus far. The percentage change for Trump was 0.48% and for Biden it is currently 2.12%. This is obviously only a rough comparison that may not be the right one to make, but I still see no evidence that Biden’s policies are failing at this point.

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

The Troll has been staggering his disruptions for about a week now. The Troll is using his "links" to take Readers off the communications threads. The TROLL has established a new modus operand volume will increase, a form of platform disruption. IrRecommend accurate "reports" to Substack Inc.

Expand full comment
Judith Dyer's avatar

I reported him several times. He carries on.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Who's the troll...

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

I have a theory, it is someone in Gothenburg NE with at least 2 family generations going back per some data on Ancestry. Nothing wrong with the Midwest. Probate diagrams help some;

I'd say a middle age MALE maybe 52 who left the 'Moon OF Alabama' MoU) meme which did not go so well. Update: Edit per that Special Someone. ... Moon OF Alabama, got it.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Bryan Sean McKown is a creepy cyber-stalker

Expand full comment
Jen Andrews's avatar

I think you read the data incorrectly. Credit card debt is not necessarily “a sure sign of consumer distress”.

It might be optimism that they can afford to pay off the big expenditure.

I am so tired of armchair economists — or “real “ ones like Larry Summers, who couldn’t see a housing disaster bearing down on him like a Mack truck— throwing out Bs as if it were fact.

And don’t think you’re going to argue with me because I’m a woman. I’m an analytical chemist with a PhD in medicinal chemistry. Math doesn’t scare me.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

I think I phrased my earlier observation inaccurately.

The fact that we now have the highest level of credit card debt ever recorded is a sure sign of financial stress among people with little to spare.

Expand full comment
Judith L Hubbard's avatar

If we wish to discuss Ukraine, the authority on this platform is Dr. Timothy Snyder whose Yale course on the history of Ukraine is available here. No one need engage the eagerly spouting propaganda of John Schmeekle.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

Regarding the current war in Ukraine, Dr. Timothy Snyder is a shameless propagandist.

Expand full comment
Sherry Wolf's avatar

As a retired accountant, I believe high credit card debt is a sign of poor financial education. I've had many clients who had mountains of credit card debt seemingly for one of two reasons. Either they did not control their spending (buying impulse items and wants rather than needs) or it never occurred to them that they could pay it off. I once had a client who got a new credit card and told me the best thing about it was that he was not allowed to carry a balance (it had to be paid in full each month). I replied that he could pay off all of his credit cards each month. He looked at me with such confusion... like the idea had never occurred to him. I think many people in this country think this way.

Expand full comment
Judith Dyer's avatar

I have never paid a cent for interest on a credit which was the only card available when I had my business in the '70's and '80's...I did NOT want to pay for something I did not get. Or, be paying for something I had already used up. Now, I have a card for Amazon purchases which is paid automatically. And, several debit cards to get pesos at the Mexican ATMs.

A Frontline video from 2009 tells the tale of what a racket it is. Low income people pay way more in fines and interest than high income people.

I told the fellow who cleans and gardens here: do not buy anything on credit. It's a worse rip off in Mexico. The population is very uneducated, even worse than those in the USA. You don't need anything you have to put on a credit card. The only debt should be for a house or a car. Interest rates on houses is now 7%...that is nothing compared to credit cards charging 29%!

Expand full comment
Bill Katz's avatar

Agree. I live debt free. And when I buy my next house, it will be with cash. I’m glad I can.

Expand full comment
Nora Handler's avatar

Exactly, the fantasy that Biden is anything but a warmonger poking both Russia and China and putting us in great danger of nuclear war is a PR game by the Biden administration. Sigh. .

Expand full comment
Jon Margolis's avatar

Lies, damn lies and statistics? I’m surprised that you admit it.

Expand full comment
Chris Hierholzer's avatar

You should try to stop wallowing in the darkness that you created John.

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

How's that for a non-response.

Expand full comment
D4N's avatar

🤡

Expand full comment
D4N's avatar

🤡

Expand full comment
Bill Bachofner's avatar

Not on planet earth, this John....

Expand full comment
John Schmeeckle's avatar

You can afford to pretend and not care, betting that you will no longer be on Planet Earth when the combined follies of Republicans and Democrats over the decades wipe out Social Security and Medicare and pension investments of those who are a bit younger.

Expand full comment
D4N's avatar

🤡

Expand full comment
Bill Katz's avatar

Well you’re suddenly making a little sense but not by much.

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

Bill, the Troll changed tactics & timing about a week ago.

If anyone really needs to be distracted to another Topic, a useful Topic, I recommend "The Atlantic" article just posted a 3 hours ago jointly by Lawrence Tribe & former Judge Michael J. Luttig titled

"The Constitution Prohibits Trump From Ever Being PresidentT Again" Tfg is barred from being President again by Section 3 of the 14th Amendment. We do NOT have to wait for a successful prosecution by Jack Smith or Fani Willis.

Expand full comment
Judith L Hubbard's avatar

YES, Robert Weber has posted, reposted, noted, etc. the article by CREW you can download the 90 page with sources complete for that approach:

https://www.citizensforethics.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/20230714_CREW_Report_Final.pdf

Expand full comment
Judith Dyer's avatar

2 very smart men. I saw Judge Luttig right after the Jan 6 insurrection and totally fell "in love" with him.

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

The Judge, JML, was a critical player in the collapse of the J6 attack as he advised Pence he not have any power to be the catalyst or lynchpin of the attempted coup.

Expand full comment
Judith Dyer's avatar

I thought that on that day, Pence was very courageous, a proper hero.

A friend said "No, he was just doing his job".

I still give him credit for that, but, not for much else.

Expand full comment
Judith Dyer's avatar

I downloaded it (and increased the size) and read several pages. yes yes yes...but will any Maga or Repub. give a good god damn.

I knew before he ran that he was unqualified and predicted that IF he won, when his term ended, we would have to send in a SWAT squad to extract him from the White House.

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

It does not matter what the shrinking number of magas think or the R party which has functionally collapsed. Women pissed at the destruction of the right to control their own bodies & have access to birth control, meds & privacy, "Independents", no NAMED party voters , professional single women especially in Northern Virginia & other states, young people who will vote along with NEW voters will determine the 2024 Election.

Expand full comment
Judith Dyer's avatar

Really really hoping that this is the perfect final solution to "the problem".

"The Constitution Prohibits Trump From Ever Being PresidentT Again" Tfg is barred from being President again by Section 3 of the 14th Amendment.

Expand full comment
Bryan Sean McKown's avatar

Sunday News Cycle Update: Judy, I will post any significant response to the Tribe-Judge Pathway here. Well Judy, that did not take long:

At 10:48 pm last night, Heather Cox Richardson, our famous 19th Century Expert, posted the full Text of the key of the 14th Amendment, Section 3. More importantly, Heather highlighted a "preprint" of a Law Review article that was posted on August 14, 6 days ago.

Notably, the article was written by two (2) "Federalist Society" icons, William Baude of the University of Chicago Law School & Michael S. Paulsen of St. Thomas School of Law who both vigorously SUPPORT the Constitutional way to DQ & get rid of tfg.

Importantly, Baude & Paulsen point out that Amendment 14, Section 3 is "self executing" meaning Trump is DQ'd from Office NOW for trying to steal the 2020 Election from tens of Millions of American Voters.

Recap: You have a famous Judge, two (2) "Federalist" Professors & the top Constitutional lawyer in the Country, LAWRENCE TRIBE, that say we are done with the Orange Menace. ⚖️ ... ;)

Expand full comment
Judith Dyer's avatar

I have watched and read everything. The CREW report...L. Tribe and Judge Luttig,( I love every word that comes out of his mouth ) I truly believe this will be seconded by the SCOTUS...even as messed up as it is. The cancer looks like it's going into remission.

Expand full comment