7 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
James R. Carey's avatar

I'm going to express the same meaning in different words.

Don't be naively optimistic, but whatever you do, don't be pessimistic because pessimism is a self-fulfilling prophecy. If I act based on the assumption I won't catch a fish, then I won't fish, and then I won't catch a fish.

Expand full comment
Ned McDoodle's avatar

Very good point about pessimism. I do despair at times. Still trying to figure out what the HELL happened to 'my' America of the Great Society with Big Business support.

Expand full comment
Ned McDoodle's avatar

Back then, moderate conservatives, like my parents, viewed themselves as part of a larger system that included liberals. Like the pick used by an ice climbers, liberals would throw the pick ahead (prudently with the influence of moderate liberals).

The moderate conservatives would pull the rest of us in by making the progressive policies fiscally sustainable; at times the further right conservatives might intervene when a policy had failed or was repudiated by the populace.

It does show that what made the W.W.II generation was not the Depression; that made the generation good. Not the war; that made the generation great. It is what those men and women did AFTER W.W.II through 1968 that made them the Greatest Generation.

But that is likely my na├пve view. After all, I was a deeply informed intellectual at the age of eight back then.

Expand full comment
James R. Carey's avatar

By describing the conservative/progressive interaction pattern, you're accurately describing a specific manifestation of a frequently observed and frequently described phenomenon that I would argue has been recurring for thousands of generations since the origin of our species. So, I would say your view is not naive. Instead, it's in the right direction. Keep going, and you'll get there.

Alternatively, click on my profile link. I think I can save you a lot of time, energy, and attention.

Expand full comment
Ned McDoodle's avatar

Thank you, James. On your profile now -- ┬┐where do I go from there? I am not familiar with sub-stack, truth be told.

Expand full comment
James R. Carey's avatar

I'm new to this too. I thought you would see that I've written a book and see its Amazon listing. Regardless, here's the link: https://amazon.com/dp/1779415710.

Hope that works. If not, you should be able to find it with a Google search. The book's name is The Wisdom Theory by James R. Carey.

Expand full comment
Ned McDoodle's avatar

Ordering the book. Thanks.

Expand full comment