4 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Christy's avatar

There have been numerous pieces of journalism of late regarding the number of local schools districts that are poisoning their children with distorted history. And that is a huge reason for why so many in our country don’t know historical facts. Most of us have enough trouble keeping up with what’s needed of us in our own little bubbles and are therefore challenged to pay attention to what has happened to the curriculum in some hyper partisan districts out west.

Expand full comment
Sherry's avatar

I really am not making a judgment about your statement, however, I don't think it is fair to make broad generalized statements that there have been "numerous pieces of journalism" "regarding local school districts poisoning their children." What pieces of journalism? Which publications? Which journalists? Which school districts? While I would never make a broad statement that such a thing never happens, my original post refers to the fact that most social science teachers are dedicated to truth in teaching. Keep in mind that public school teachers are required to teach content as guided by state-mandated standards and benchmarks. I have worked on those committees so I am familiar with those processes. There truly is a dedication to best teaching practices and exploring well-rounded historical facts. I think well-rounded is the key. In order to provide the best education possible, we need to teach about both the good decisions, experiences, and social movements as well as those areas that had a less positive impact. We need to acknowledge that decision-makers, while perhaps making what they thought were the best decisions may have in fact, have negatively impacted The US and Americans. People aren't perfect. Our nation is not perfect. We seek to create a more perfect union but make mistakes. Just as in life, mistakes and failures are learning opportunities. The best history education helps students to think critically about the past, including the mistakes and failures. To ignore this history is to prevent young people from learning and understanding how past choices created particular results. I value education highly and, to me, that means looking at our past as honestly as we can, warts and all.

Expand full comment
Christy's avatar

Here’s a Cato Institute (Libertarian Institute think tank) Twitter page that highlights various controversies over curriculum. There appears to be much confusion over historical fact and the interpretation of history. Let me be very clear, I’m a strong proponent of government that loves and takes care of all people. I despise the premise of Libertarianism. But the Twitter page gives credence to my assertion on the problem of an accurate curriculum.

Expand full comment
Christy's avatar

LOL. I’m not your “student”. I offered my perspective as someone who reads widely and nonstop. It’s not up to me to provide you with a list of sources and Google couldn’t be much easier to use. I speak of local school boards primarily. My spouse is an educator, I’m not disparaging teachers, I have great respect for the vast majority. As with any profession there can be bad apples, I have experienced history teachers who don’t flinch at teaching propaganda.

https://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/us_6000bce3c5b62c0057bb711f?fbclid=IwAR3SIF2NtfUnfB9pO6YHUvs5NH_zJpwaqObtc8Ybv5HHVT5PeD8aMYTDX24

Expand full comment