401 Comments

Well, Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed because 10 righteous could not be found. Looks like Republicans have the same problem.

Expand full comment

Trump having dinner with Ye, the antisemitic artist (I don’t know who and what else he hates) and white supremacist, admirer of Russian president Vladimir Putin, Nick Fuentes, just before Thanksgiving is a historical marker. But for me, and for so many others, it was no big deal. Trump has been feasting on fascism for how long?

They met in 1973, Donald Trump and Roy Cohn, the American lawyer and prosecutor who first gained attention as Senator Joseph McCarthy's chief counsel.

‘Cohn had become the premier practitioner of hardball deal-making in New York, having mastered the arcane rules of the city’s Favor Bank (the local cabal of interconnected influence peddlers) and its magical ability to provide inside fixes for its machers and rogues.’

“You knew when you were in Cohn’s presence you were in the presence of pure evil,” said lawyer Victor A. Kovner, who had known him for years. Cohn’s power derived largely from his ability to scare potential adversaries with hollow threats and spurious lawsuits. And the fee he demanded for his services? Ironclad loyalty.(VanityFair)

Between his father, Fred Trump, and Roy Cohn, Donald J. Trump was well schooled.

Nick Fuentes is nothing compared to Trump’s favorites: North Korea’s Chairman Kim, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, President Vladimir Putin, Chinese President Xi Jinping, President Erdogan of Turkey, Rodrigo Duterte, Philippines and Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi, Egypt.

We’re referring to the former president of the US, who is still worshiped by many millions of Americans. Do they care who Trump dines with unless it is President Joseph R. Biden?

Expand full comment

Yes, Fern, there’s that history and yet… not shocking that so much of TFG’s, his family’s and cohort’s connections were corrupt and this “news” was available for us to research and read. (excluding repubs? Or that didn’t matter?)

The repub voters didn’t care. Then and now: win anyway they can. At any cost. And they are completely focused on taking down and destroying President Biden at any cost to him and the USA.

Expand full comment

Irenie, They have to destroy the country to save it. I don't refer to our moral compasses, consciences, or democratic principles when examining their behavior. They've got a different drummer. We will turn around the ones we can and shut down those who threaten our survival.

Expand full comment

Fern, I hope time is on the side of Truth and Justice.

Expand full comment

Irenie, let's not starve Democracy's strong advocates. It is time for activities that nourish us and time to learn, teach and discover with the people we love and like a lot. Our spirits need to relax. Remember how Pete Seeger encouraged us to sing? Withal, it is time to connect with one another in playful and caring ways.

Expand full comment

I'm afraid that relaxation can't be number one on our list. People are awake for the 1st time since 2016. We need to fill in the blanks about

the dangers of his adding to his sociopathic pals. A small group of them

can take our country back to the mental/emotional skids we were on

over the last several years. We know the stale ones; this is the fresh team.

Expand full comment

Can we live long enough? I hope we don't end up like Ukraine. My heart breaks for the pleople that live there!

Expand full comment

Time may be, but big money sure isn't.

Expand full comment

Some of them still don’t care. I was making calls for Sen. Warnock yesterday and got a guy who told me he and his wife are Republicans and T___p supporters. He hung up (hanged up?) before I could tell him there’s still time for redemption. By the way, if you’re not helping the Warnock campaign, there are many ways to do so. The one thing not needed is money: as of a couple of days ago the campaign had more than $20 million.

Expand full comment

This dinner is foreshadowing of Trump's down and dirty strategy for 2024.

Appealing again to bottom-feeder voters. Get a celebrity on board (Kanye this time instead of Walker.) Get someone who hates democracy (Fuentes instead of Stewart Rhodes.) So predictable.

Expand full comment

When it was revealed that Cohn had been a Trump "coach" it should have been the end of Trumps political ambitions. It would have been - in a nation that really thought Joe McCarthy was evil. But millions lapped up McCarthy's hate like high priced ice cream.

And their progeny are out there now - 10s of millions of them. Haters of equality. Haters of tolerance. Haters of "others".

But there are more of us than them. Shame them. Shun them. Shunt them into political oblivion. We will prevail. 2024 will be a powerful bright blue statement of democracy.

Expand full comment

I will never understand people who admire Hitler and Mussolini, two of history’s biggest losers. Think about it: Hitler took Europe’s biggest economy and turned it into a smoking ruin, with millions of its people dead, and millions more enslaved. Mussolini turned Italy into a laughingstock and a tragedy. Putin is joining them in the losers’ brigade. What’s to like?

Expand full comment

I imagine part of the problem is people's lack of knowledge about history. How many actually know much about what happened in both world wars (one was to end all wars)? “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” Santayana

Expand full comment

But they kept “The Master Race” myth alive. And they proved that even smoldering destruction, humiliation, and starvation cannot kill the perennial need in some to feel superior over others.

Expand full comment

The conflict that people wrestle with internally - am I good enough? gets externalized so that they never have to acknowledge that it's all about their own feelings of inadequacy. Instead they make others the "bad" guy who they can blame for all their own failures. Unfortunately the euphoria they feel at being the victor is short lived, so once again they have to find another person or group to target. A story older than time and practically biblical. If we refuse to "know thyself" we are doomed to repeat this.

Expand full comment

So true! Forget the fascist horrible anti-human ideology. If you can. And just look at the ruination they created. They failed!!!

Expand full comment

Some of this had to do with how children in Germany were raised during that time. The Dr. Spock of that time was a man who advocated for "spare the rod and spoil the child". His idea was to beat the willfulness out of the child, until he/she became submissive and obedient. When a leader arrives promising the same kind of treatment of the "bad ones" it appeals to large swaths of the population. Couple that with the vengeance woven through the Armistice agreement after WWI, the country was defeated, not only in war but in spirit. Violence breeds violence.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
November 29, 2022
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Sounds like you had a tough journey, and perhaps made use of it, by raising your children differently. The saying is "spare the rod and spoil the child" suggesting that if you don't hit your children they will somehow spoil, whatever that means. Lots of people have been raised that way, and continue to be raised that way, unfortunately. It takes work and courage to challenge those ideas passed down to us. Good for you.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
November 29, 2022
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Perhaps the key point in who sits at the table of the deranged is the age of the guests, who will target the other young, unformed and disenfranchised. Gen Z and the next up are a prime target for these incorporated anti-human types. They're all working for the big mouth Ponzi $cheme in the $ky.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Fern!

Expand full comment

From your keyboard to G*d’s scrreen

Expand full comment

They were never really “righteous” in the best sense....

Expand full comment

I love righteous Biblical references.

Expand full comment

Hahaha, gives me a laugh with this current crop of “christians.”

Expand full comment

Nevoustrumpezpas "I love righteous Biblical references."

100 Bible Verses about Righteousness

https://www.openbible.info/topics/righteousness

Expand full comment

A great comparison! Well put, JennSH. May I add that the Sounds of Silence tells it all. The words of the prophets are written on the subway walls. And men's room walls. And Fox.

Expand full comment

Jenn, those bible stories are more like todays news than I would ever have believed!!!

Expand full comment

Why on earth does a 24-year old get any political traction whatsoever? For any Congressional or Presidential delegates or aspirants to knuckle to someone whose brain hasn’t even fully developed is nuts.

Expand full comment

I believe, Deborah, that 45 is “knuckling” to much bigger and darker forces than a puny nazibaby like Fuentes. Look at the $500,000 in bitcoin that was transferred to Fuentes and his goons in December 2020, one month before the attempted overthrow of our duly elected government. A French man was the source (his name is not known publicly) of the “donation” to Fuentes’ group and now the “donor” is dead by his own hand. So, ANYBODY shouldn’t have that kind of sway. A Mussolini lover to boot (pun intended...).

Expand full comment

Thank you Elizabeth. Yes, in this case 'follow the bitcoins.' Per the IRS, the America First Foundation (AFF) is a 501(c)4 tax organization. As such AFF must file a Form 8976. Per the Southern Poverty Law Center, (SPLC) Michelle Malkin sits on the Board of the AFF 501(c)4 and is the "mentor to Fuentes & some of his [Fuentes'] followers who refer to [Malkin] as 'Mommy" Mommy and her "social organization" are not "nice people". AFF seeks to make unlimited contributions to seditionist candidates.

Expand full comment

Perhaps I don't pay enough attention to the white nationalist crowd, but are Filipinos considered "white" now? I looked up Ms. Malkin and, besides her nutso political views, she seems to be a lovely young woman of Phillipine ancestry. Is there a narrative about her ethnicity/race that I'm too lazy to hunt for? What a strange world: I guess next, Fuentes, Mallin, and Clarence Thomas will stage a rally for "white rights!

Expand full comment

Yes, Dirk, they already staged that rally. It’s called the January 6, 2021 seditious insurrection. That was the rally for “white rights”: you hit the nail on the head! I

Expand full comment

She is another far right pundit. They are not (presently) demanding pure 'Whiteness' of their base, but that will soon change. Right now, they are just using whomever will talk their message.

Expand full comment

Malkin is proof there is indeed a second career for over-the-hill Olongapo boom-boom girls. ("former naval persons" of a certain age will get the reference)

Expand full comment

How was Malkin involved? Is there proof? I hope so!

Expand full comment

Would this be a new twist on Blackface?

Expand full comment

I was thinking the same thing.

Expand full comment

Don’t forget Ye, apparently.

Expand full comment

Lordy, I wish I could have seen the look on Trump's face when Ye asked him to be Ye's running mate. Oh-ho, that must have been as sight!

Expand full comment

wow...I didn't know about this bitcoin involvement, and I try to be very informed ! I'd like to learn more.

Expand full comment

Absolutely horrifying. Yes, we must follow those damn bitcoins….thank you Bryan.

Expand full comment

I had not heard anything about this bitcoin transfer! Wow. Fuentes is an out and out Fascist. They are the boldest they've ever been, even more that during the 1930s .

Expand full comment

They haven't had any rallies in Madison Square Gardens yet.

Expand full comment

Madison Square Gardens has moved to the Internet?

Expand full comment

maybe it moved to the Capitol Jan 6th?

Expand full comment

the planning has

Expand full comment

Yet being the operative word, TC. OMG.

Expand full comment

Attempted like.

Expand full comment

1939 would be hard to beat

Expand full comment

not these days with those rabid thumpers and trumpers... i can easily envision it. can't you, Jeri?

Expand full comment

Linda, you may want to listen to Rachel Maddow's podcast Ultra [<https://www.rachelmaddow.com/rachel-maddow-presents-ultra/>] to how these fascist movements evolved through the 1940's antiwar movement largely funded by Christian-right Rev. Father Coughlin, who had the largest radio audience in America at the time and his funding by Hitler and the Nazi propaganda machine

...spoiler alert:

it spread to members of Congress as well!

Expand full comment

I am infuriated at the lack of investigation into the role many congress people played in the attempted coup. Up to and including Ginny Thomas and her compromised husband.

Expand full comment

Fascists for years have been putting guns in the hands of starving gangs of 10 years old and up boys, pointing a gun to their head, feeding them, paying them and forcing them to commit horrendous crimes against humanity. It is a sick practice that often is instigated to protect the industry of the colonizer, whether it be drugs, diamonds, mining interests, oil and gas, and pretty soon, water.

Expand full comment

Not sure 'fascist' is the right term for those political gangs; the term is usually used for governments.

Expand full comment

while I detest Fuentes, your remark about someone that young deserving political traction, is ageist. Maxwell Frost, a 25 y.o. Democrat, just won the election for Florida’s 10th Congressional District. By your comment he does not deserve any traction. Maxwell was also one of the young people who organized the March for our Lives against gun violence when he was 21.

Methinks you were a bit hasty in slamming an age group.

Expand full comment

Cynthia At 89 I have a distinct view of ‘ageism.’ At 25 I had the answers, but didn’t know the questions. Now I know the questions but have few if any answers. Also, the finest wine after 64 years is almost always spoiled. Perhaps, at 90, I’ll acquire greater wisdom, though I consider that doubtful.

Expand full comment

It is impossible to compare ages as technology, science, and the arts have moved us forward faster. Someone 25 today has a completely different skill and experience set than someone 25 decades ago. My 8 year old grandson is learning to code. What they watch, hear, see, experience is much different from children who grew up on Sesame Street.

Expand full comment

Well said. Every generation discovers solutions before they understand the problem. The wise within that generation spend time and energy clarifying the questions and working at connecting the two. It will be the passion among those who have yet to become wise that stear the quest and make the difference until the next generation takes up the effort. The underlying questions about how to (or how they can) create a just democracy will likely be different but in the longer view of history quite similar. A just society and the governance of a democracy is not an outcome, an end result, but a process, a way to build or create within, some maner of living with each other in such ways as we, the members and organization, improve in connection to the diversity of those living in its presence. That is why when we were young, we discover the answers and thusly began the work, the process, and the commitment to bettering rather than fixing or fitting it to some old model or some prior result.

Expand full comment

Well said, Fred. Thank you!

Expand full comment

i love this, Fred!!! so well described!! thank you for sharing your perspective!

Expand full comment

Just live it

Expand full comment

At 90 we forget the questions we bragged that we knew.

Expand full comment

Molly A year from now I may know the answer—or is it the question? Have I passed my prime, am awaiting my prime, or never had a prime? How will I know?

Expand full comment

Keith

You are sharper than most who are half your age!

So appreciative of your learned perspective as we wander through the weeds to attempt to understand this chapter in history. Without this Substack community, without Heather connecting the historical dots to today's events, we'd all be lost souls.

Expand full comment

By then you won’t care. Just have fun and smile.

Expand full comment

Love this, Keith!

Expand full comment

Cynthia, I agree age should never be a factor. Chuck Grassley was as terrible at 35 as he is now at 89, just reelected to the Senate. Maxwell Frost was duly elected by We The People. He is deserving of every support necessary to help him develop and grow into a powerful leader for good. I am sorry the comment seemed to be slamming his age group. Thank you for pointing it out.

Expand full comment

I didn't see "ageism"; what stood out for me was that both young men are 24 and already strong enough to be a force, one for good and one for evil. It's the under-twenties who will shape what happens next.

Expand full comment

The statement wasn’t qualified. It merely said that one so young wasn’t deserving of attention. It did not say one or the other.

Expand full comment

Fuentes reminds me of all the 24 year old morons I knew 50 years ago, the difference being he's a Nazi and they were Bourgeois Bolsheviks.

Expand full comment

I think your labels for them, as I recall them from my own experience, was too generous. Where I came from, I remember them as simply stupid and real assholes to boot.

Expand full comment

Those are very accurate descriptive terms. I still don't forgive any of the still-unrepentant Weatherman crew.

Expand full comment

They were a tiny fraction of the New Left, ignored by the rest though loved by the media. Don't be distracted.

Expand full comment

Sorry, they were the faction of the New Left that wiped out the rest, and the rest of the Trotskyites, Maoists, True Marxists, True Communists, Yippies and the rest of the other splinter groups all had their heads up their asses too. I speak from experience.

Expand full comment

Tom I recall that the Communists were ‘despicable’ before WW II. Then, as Churchill phrased it, “The enemy of my enemy is my friend,’ Uncle Joe became our ‘almost democratic’ ally. My British cousin, with us during the London blitz, and Dick Pearson, who later became an officer at the National Geographic, loudly sang patriotic Soviet songs that would have prompted federal investigation a scant few years later.

As for ‘socialism.’ For some a dirty word, then the Great Society including Medicare and much more, and now increasingly a Republican dirty word with Medicare and Social Security in the cross hairs.

I haven’t a clue whether it’s good or bad to be ‘woke.’ My 21 year old grandson tells me that woke is passé without my ever experiencing it.

Expand full comment

Maxwell is so impressive, heard him interviewed on PBS Newshour, I think it was. And he started working on gun safety when he was 16 and became involved as a result of the Sandy Hook massacre.

Expand full comment

I had the same thought about Maxwell Alejandro Frost, as well as David Hogg and Greta Thunberg. Also MI senator who went viral with her speech denouncing hate, Mallory McMarrow, said if we want to get young people voting, we need to have young candidates. Of course all of this doesn't make Mr. Fuentes any less of a white supremacist......

Expand full comment

No it doesn’t make Mr. Fuentes less of a white supremacist. Sadly, though he is not unique. There are more than a few who believe like him and have through the ages. What I wonder about is what is it that perpetuates such beliefs in people through the ages? Is there some evolutionary purpose?

Seriously, this pattern keeps repeating . . . in the present instance, we’re seeing a repeat of behavior and politics we saw in the thirties for example. What is it that keeps human civilization from learning this lesson once and for all?

Expand full comment

Thanks, Chaplain, for that reminder including also Mallory McMarrow. terrific speech. I want to listen to it again plus print it.

Expand full comment

Cynthia, you’re right; I was too hasty in my comment. One’s prefrontal cortex takes about 25 years to form fully, but there are plenty of principled and hardworking people younger than that. Calling myself out, I’d say I was making a quick judgement of Fuentes based on his age and views, though age certainly doesn’t determine political stance.

If we take age out of the equation, I’d say that plenty of other points in this dispatch deserve incredulity: the Trump-Ye mutual admiration society, Trump’s failure to repudiate what Fuentes stands for and articulates, and Kevin McCarthy’s apparent willingness to accept the positions of Fuentes, Marjorie Green, and their ilk. The more extreme the Republican Party becomes, the more accepting of hate fringe its leaders and would-be leaders are, the more naked their will to power appears — even when the foundations of their beliefs contradict (in both Ye’s and Fuentes’s case) the value of their own existence.

These things remind me of my reactions during the last Presidential Administration, a time in which Trump and the Republicans blew through so many norms and rewrote national policy on what seemed a daily basis. That McCarthy (certainly not known for his adherence to principles of decency, but still) would bow now to the far left, as exemplified by Fuentes and Marjorie Green — well, I understand it as part of his bid for the Speakership, but I think he’s digging a deep hole for himself, his party, and the national interest. The nuttiness of the Ye-Trump-Fuentes constellation sure looks obvious to me; the fact that TFG and his pals still get any attention, much less fawning attention and supplication, feels both pathetic and dangerous.

Thanks for pushing this conversation further.

Expand full comment

Woops — I meant far right!

Expand full comment

I suppose it would depend on the 24-year old. Trump's 66-year-old emotional development was halted somewhere in the single digits, while teen Greta Thunberg has showed a fair degree of precocious maturity. I am only a year younger than Trump, but have the sense that our national political cast of characters might benefit from a bit more youth.

I do believe that every age has fortes and foibles, and that while much can be gained from long engaged experience, that assumes one was actively learning to begin with, and not grown complacent over time. We need a robust array of diverse, good-faith perspectives from all ages, which is not to say predators of any age are welcome.

Expand full comment

YES!!

Expand full comment

Agree. He's 24, didn't finish college, and is half Mexican "Fuentes" meaning he is anti-himself, besides antisemitic, similar weirdness of Ye. I don't get it.

Expand full comment

Vicious fools like Fuentes make up a small fraction of young activists.

More typical are:

Greta Thunberg

David Hogg

Malala Yousafzai

Thandiwe Abdullah

Jazz Jennings

The millions of young people who turned around the 2022 midterms

And lots more....

Young people are working hard to save our country and our planet, which we have handed to them in a state of serious disrepair.

Expand full comment

Absolutely!

Expand full comment

And he was what, 19, when he committed to moving GOP further to the right? But tfg thinks he "gets" him. Like calls to like. Good material there!

Expand full comment

Mental age of about toddler

Expand full comment

You can certainly tell a lot about a person by whom he hangs out with. Wake up America...geeze.

Expand full comment

Exactly, but if you spew enough hate, it attracts the vermin like carrion

Expand full comment

He’ll be the same at 44. It’s more than an age thing, but I hear you.

Expand full comment

What makes a person a nazi? Is there some sort of genetic defect? Or environmental factor? It seems people like Fuentes have a thirst for power, and they have learned that inciting hatred of others by blaming all one's difficulties in life on those "others" is very attractive to many. It's so much easier than trying to make life better for everyone. 😪

Expand full comment

Corporate is cultivating new whips among the disenfranchised Gen Z and after, because they saw younger people step up in the midterms. They also see this group being serious about the changing climate and the availability of water, which is being privatized in plain sight with little opposition. Resources are the goal, and Risk is their game.

Expand full comment

Let's start right now to fully understand that the real creature vying to be the prince of darkness in 2024 as leader of the GOP is Ron De Santis. The mainstream press has to lay out for the public everything about him , his wife, his close aides and financial backers to show they are not fit to lead the country. De Santis is Trump with brains. There is nothing about him that is praiseworthy. Nor has anyone in the press told me how a creature like Fuentes sprung into the prominence he has. Who spawned him, who shaped him how did a bad seed like this get to where he commands any following. Until they come back with that info they are not doing their job. Going forward no nice words about DeSantis. Trump will take care of his own self-destruction. Sadly there appear to be no electable Republicans who have any idea of how to make this country one in which we can have pride . Right now the only party working toward that end is the democratic party.

Professor Richardson has framed the issues raised by this Trump dinner with scum like Fuentes and Ye better than anyone in the mainstream press.

Expand full comment

You speak my heart. Thank you. Desantis is a fascist and he will destroy democracy in our country if given the chance. Educational experts have determined that his policies here in Florida ensure a next generation of ignorant racists to add to his base. Again, thank you for your eloquence is recognizing that Desantis is trump 2.0-smarter and intentionally cruel.

Expand full comment

I agree with every negative comment here about DeSantis. But while he may be smarter than TFG (which is not a high bar), he's lacking one important asset. Several political talking heads have made the point that DeSantis does not have TFG's ability to entertain, charm and sway a crowd with his personality. I'm not saying DeSantis is not a threat. But lacking TFG's evil "pied piper personality" is a major failing that will not help DeSantis gather followers outside of Florida among the majority of people in the country who are not familiar with him.

Expand full comment

Yes, you do have a point, CC. Also, the country (except FL & TX) seems to be rejecting the MAGAts in general. Saw a poll on Breaking Points last week that showed people disapprove of MAGAt more than they disapprove of cheeto.

Expand full comment

Tx and Fl subjected to the worse voter “integrity,” I mean suppression. And yet, according to the Dallas Morning News, the Dems are scratching their heads wondering what they did wrong. WTF Dems, you were screwed from the git go. Don’t you remember leaving the state to protest. I’m sure other Repub cretins are looking at Tx and Fl and thinking, let’s do that. It worked like a charm and nobody seems to care….

Expand full comment

Today, i believe even more that you're onto something here, CC. DeSantis and many other 'smart' Rs (who potentially wanna run in '24) are staying silent on this stuff. So far, no one really challenges cheeto... and that still leaves him the R leader. They're afraid to cross him because he still dominates the base? Of course, he hasn't been indicted yet... and who knows if he ever will be. Or if he is... will that cause them to all rally for him??

Expand full comment

Desantis is trump 2.0-smarter and intentionally cruel. <-- We all recognize who he is.

Expand full comment

I don't think we can count on the mainstream press to do what you are proposing; they didn't for tfg and I can't think of any reason why they would re DeSantis. Murdoch has apparently turned against tfg but certainly not against DeSantis.

Expand full comment

Aren’t there 5 decent Republicans period?

Expand full comment

Assume this is a rhetorical question. Rs prove again and again that they are spineless and the party of

death

Expand full comment

No. And I certainly wouldn’t count Kristol among them.

Expand full comment

Kristol is someone I used to seriously disagree with and dislike, but when push came to shove, it turned out he could find his moral compass still in his backpack and take it out and start following it. He walks the walk as well as talks the talk. And if you think that's not important then you have so much yet to learn about politics that I doubt you could do it in all the years you have left.

Expand full comment

Push does not always come to shove.

Many of us have come to realize in recent years, the vast majority of Republicans support authoritarianism over democracy. At this point, anything other than full-throated denunciation of the majority of Republican politicians is inadequate.

Expand full comment