24 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Lynell(VA by way of MD&DC)'s avatar

I am following all you say here, George. I do get stuck on the word "educated" as a requirement for maintaining a democracy. To me, that word connotes those who have attained the heights of a formal education, something of a turnoff for many who do not belong to that club.

I personally belong to and am proud of being a member of the "woke" club, meaning "alert to racial prejudice and discrimination...a broader awareness of social inequalities such as racial injustice, sexism, and denial of LGBT rights." Just my two cents!

Expand full comment
George A. Polisner's avatar

A good point Lynell. When I think of "educated" it is not as a graduate or post-graduate level individual. I think of a fundamental education that facilitates being able to process information and distinguish between propaganda, disinformation, and lies versus information with a basis in fact.

For example, someone who might question if someone with multiple bankruptcies and massive debt is a shrewd businessperson who should lead the United States.

If we just elect people on the basis of who has the cooler yard sign -that is no longer a meaningful democracy. And it is incumbent upon us, if we truly care to continue to evolve a vibrant, meaningful democracy -to make funding for education an absolute priority, to honor and pay teachers well, to not allow the classroom to be politicized by eradicating actual history, and to provide affordable higher education for all who would like to pursue it.

Expand full comment
Lynell(VA by way of MD&DC)'s avatar

Excellent, George! And what I'm saying is perhaps people first need to be woke (alert) as a precursor to the idea of being educated.

Expand full comment
Heather Kirk's avatar

To educate yourself on these issues is to awaken knowledge and understanding. But, you need critical thinking skills to do that. Teach more critical thinking in schools, let's get these kids thinking deeply and discussing everything.

Expand full comment
George A. Polisner's avatar

True -I think it is a responsibility we all share together. Call it "Wokeness" -because that sure upsets Ron DeFascist (and who among us doesn't enjoy that!), but education is a necessary element to evolve toward a better future together.

Expand full comment
Mary Hardt's avatar

George, a good example of non-post-graduate education is the Yukon High School (Yukon Oklahoma) Reality Check for 9th grade students. Each student is randomly given a yearly salary and then goes to booths for banking, groceries, housing, childcare, transportation, entertainment, charity, insurance, etc. to see the impact of not having enough money to pay bills and choices to be made. Perhaps something like that about choosing which parts of the constitution/amendments to keep or discard?

Expand full comment
George A. Polisner's avatar

That sounds like an excellent program. There's probably too much memorization and not enough pragmatic application of knowledge in terms of real world responsibility.

Expand full comment
Barbara Keating's avatar

George I think, sadly, that educators (K-12) now “teach to the test”—given changes made to teaching “requirements” and standardized testing…it becomes rote memorization, not real learning.

Expand full comment
George A. Polisner's avatar

Yes, I know many wonderful teachers who are overworked, underpaid, and constrained from truly being educators.

This needs to change. Some of the budget for defense needs to shift to education and to climate before there is nothing left to defend.

Expand full comment
Kathy Clark's avatar

Uhhh, part of the problem is that money is going to charter and private schools.

Expand full comment
George A. Polisner's avatar

Good point Kathy. Another tactic is to erode the funding for public institutions, then to say “Look! They’re failing!!!” And then accelerate the erosion and flow to private institutions. It truly is disgusting.

Expand full comment
Ally House (Oregon)'s avatar

That study segment sounds fascinating.

Expand full comment
JennSH from NC's avatar

Ted Cruz, Josh Hawley, and Tom Cotton are all "educated." Their "ideas" are horrible for the average people in America. Look at Hawley's wife, Erin, arguing against mephipristone.

Expand full comment
George A. Polisner's avatar

True. An educated, informed, and engaged society provides a better defense against educated people (or anyone) looking to abuse, exploit, and concentrate power. Education in and of itself doesn’t constrain how it is applied.

Expand full comment
Lynell(VA by way of MD&DC)'s avatar

Said in that way, George, you have my permission to keep "educated" in your mantra...LOL!

Expand full comment
George A. Polisner's avatar

Lynell -there is always pressure to streamline and simplify! But I think I have it factored down to the prime elements. 🤓

Expand full comment
Lynell(VA by way of MD&DC)'s avatar

Because of you, George, I be educated now!

Expand full comment
George A. Polisner's avatar

I is proud! 🤪

Expand full comment
Ally House (Oregon)'s avatar

Morning, Lynell. I think that "educated" in the broadest sense can be viewed as "knowing how to learn" combined with being exposed to various assessment tools to evaluate information, and the ability to utilize critical thinking skills. And certainly "woke" as you describe it!!

Expand full comment
Lynell(VA by way of MD&DC)'s avatar

Morning, Ally!

I agree with your explanation as I imagine everyone here on this page does, too. In my mind's eye, I imagine an ensemble of folks (to be blunt, members of the lower middle class and below) who would see the word "educated" as a prerequisite to voting and conclude it does not include them.

So, maybe yes, educate them without telling them they need to be educated?

Expand full comment
Marj's avatar

Yes, I get what you are saying and agree. Educated does not mean credentialed. A lot of us 'thinkers' are self educated.

I feel strongly a very good free grade k-12 education is important to start kids on the right path.

Expand full comment
Lynell(VA by way of MD&DC)'s avatar

Absolutely, yes, Marj. We need to teach our children well.

Expand full comment
Barbara Keating's avatar

Lynell, my grandmother was born in 1898 & never went beyond high school, but was “educated” in that she was curious, open-minded and well-read. She poked and prodded and questioned as curious folks do & she fostered that in her daughters, grandkids & the great-grands who were lucky enough to know her.

Expand full comment
Lynell(VA by way of MD&DC)'s avatar

Yay for your grandmother, Barbara! The same can be said for my not-educated-beyond-high-school husband...the smartest guy I know.

Expand full comment