408 Comments

Remarkable, with all we’ve endured since 2016, I approach my 64th birthday this month a far less cynical person than I was in ‘75 when I graduated from high school. Why? I’ve been moved by the intelligence, commitment, and character of my countrymen in this fight: Sally Yates, the House Impeachment Managers all, Anthony Fauci, Alexander Vindman, Fiona Hill, Stacey Abrams, Pres. Biden, Marc E. Elias, and you Dr. Richardson. Thank you and happy Independence Day.

Expand full comment

Thank you for naming people of integrity and substance. I am so tired of reading and hearing the names of people who lack such qualities. We all know who they are.

Expand full comment

"We all know who they are." Did I land in Germany in 1933?

Expand full comment

Add my congressman, Adam Schiff, to the list.

Expand full comment

He’s already in there. He was an Impeachment Manager. I was thinking of him when I said that.

Expand full comment

I read it too quickly, David. Happy 4th to you!

Expand full comment

but R David, didn't say his name, ADAM SCHIFF, also a member of the Commission to investigate January 6th insurrection.

Expand full comment

Write your own post.

Expand full comment

Are you objecting to me adding a note or two to yours? It is not uncommon to reply in that manner.

Expand full comment

Fern, your adding names of those who inspire you is welcome. Your being negative and criticizing, not so much. ADAM SCHIFF, ADAM SCHIFF, ADAM SCHIFF. Is everyone good now? (and FYI, I contribute regularly to him).

Expand full comment

R David, I intended no criticism of you, simply responding to the interest of MaryB in seeing Schiff's name, and I added Raskin's, too. I am sorry that you saw my replies in a negative light. As indicated that was not my intention.

Expand full comment

One more point, the use of 'say his name' in my reply concerning Adam Schiff was mimicking the call in the demonstrations on behalf of George Floyd and others to 'say his name'. It would have been clearer for me to have used quotation marks. That phrase was not written to find fault with your comment. I hope that my explanations can satisfy your dissatisfaction.

Expand full comment

Say hi to the Gamble House for me. Huge Arts and Crafts movement fan here.

Expand full comment

Thank you David. I feel better having read your words and to realize that a glass can be half full and we need to look toward inspiring individuals and not fixate on those who seek to diminish others to burnish themselves. Happy 4th to you and yours.

Expand full comment

Whenever I hear that expression, I am moved to wonder if the glass is the wrong size.

I’m loving today’s comments.

Expand full comment

Mara, seen on a tee shirt - "Those who think the glass is half empty miss the point. The glass is refillable."

Expand full comment

So let's get to work refilling it, then making and filling more glasses (all the same size) and making sure that people who don't even have a glass get a nice full one.

Expand full comment

Now thats a great tee shirt!!

Expand full comment

Love it! Here's a link, followed by a snarky version!

https://pin.it/70P1kNE

https://pin.it/316LHOu

Expand full comment

Great point. I will call this to mind when I am feeling hopeless or cynical. We still have many, many good people in this country who believe in the founding aspirations, and that good will prevail.

Expand full comment

100%!

Expand full comment

I’m the same age and feel the same as you express here.

Expand full comment

Impeachment Manager, Rep. Jamie Raskin, Representative for Maryland’s 8th District also on the Commission to investigate January 6th insurrection.

Expand full comment

I am very glad about that Fern. He has amazing ability to process a great amount of information and sort it appropriately. I also was very impressed with Stacey E Plaskett, rep from US Virgin Islands during impeachment hearing. She can speak an argument very well.

Expand full comment

I did wave at noon. Hope you were free as a bird today. Ran into some bad, territorial humor. Explaining made matters worse. Thanks for winking in my direction.

Expand full comment

I did feel free today. 😉

Expand full comment

and your spirit flies...

Expand full comment

Grateful for every one of them!

Expand full comment

We need to speak these names as often as possible. Thank you.

Expand full comment

“For there is always light, if we are only brave enough to see it. If only we are brave enough to be it.”

The Hill We Climb

by Amanda Gorman.

From the Inaugural poem for the inauguration of President Joe Biden. “A skinny black girl descended from slaves…”

Expand full comment

Thank you, she was at the top of my mind to spray as well, in the “hope is here” section.

Expand full comment

Spray? Sorry, need to read first, post second.

Expand full comment

Yes.

Expand full comment

The moment of Amanda (at the inaugural) seemed to me to personify perfectly what artistry can capture to make the words "created equal" live. She inspired me to write this:

"Of a Poet"

I thought of a poet,

{on a day of poetry}

oddly, on display;

as if emerging,

from shackles shared...

suppressed

in our hearts

a hidden truth

{ echoes of: Guthrie:Simone:Lincoln:Seamus}

and

Amanda,

a rising Oshun

a risen sun

a red band cradles the mind on a woman who shatters our

quiet convention

with elegance...

her dancing hands

a lilting melody

a voice surely

not of this world,

but, of THIS moment,

celestial

transcendent

present...

made me think,

of the power

of a poet.

Expand full comment

Thank you for your art and for opening your heart, Haydn.

Expand full comment

I believe that Amanda Gorman would appreciate receiving a copy of your poem, Hayden.

Expand full comment

That, would be remarkable. I'm not sure how to do that...Ah, AndreaH, all my life I've been given an extra vowel, no worries! It's from Haydn the composer.

Expand full comment

Haydn...sorry

Expand full comment

Your words captured and expressed EXACTLY what I saw, heard and felt. Thank you! I copied her poem and added it to my art journal, with a little red ribbon as that "band" you describe. But the "dancing hands" and "lilting melody a voice surely not of this world" could not be as well placed into a visual memory.

Expand full comment

May we share Hayden? Is it published somewhere? Such a tribute to poetry.

Expand full comment

Christine, I’m humbled. Thank you. And of course you can share. It is not published. It was such a moving moment. She made me feel —-hope—-as I had not felt for so long.

Expand full comment

I know. I felt the same, Haydn. It is the vision that I hold of our young people in this country. They are so progressive and unapologetic of it. I believe they will be the force that lead us to victory in the fight to keep our Democracy and our Earth vibrant.

Expand full comment

WE are all humbled.

Expand full comment

Thank you Haydn

Expand full comment

Just beautiful….thank you

Expand full comment

beautifu, thank you!l

Expand full comment

So true, and inspiring

Expand full comment

Such emotion here. Thank you, Haydn.

Expand full comment

YES! ty.

Expand full comment

Great post, Heather. Thanks.

From my own 4th of July post over at That's Another Fine Mess:

Thomas Jefferson and John Adams, when they sat down and argued what to say in the Declaration of Independence, may have had a much different understanding their words and goal when they said “all men are created equal,” but the moment it was said, the moment it was written, it was never going to be limited to white males of property. Every person who ever read it or heard it said “Yeah, that’s for me” And that’s why for the past 245 years people have come here, and why people have striven to make that true. This is the only country founded on a revolutionary ideal, the ideal of equality of all. There are those who say the French and Russian Revolutions were more “authentic” revolutions, but millions of people didn’t risk everything after those events to go to the land of Liberty, Equality, Fraternity, or the land where the workers of the world had nothing to lose but their chains. They’ve come here, and by their coming every year, they keep the dream alive, because they arrive with it in their hearts.

On June 24, 1826, the 50th year of the signing of the Declaration of Independence, former President and author of the Declaration, 83 year old Thomas Jefferson, was asked by Roger Weightman to come to Washington D.C. to participate in the celebration of the anniversary. He was in declining health (he and John Adams would both die 10 days later on that day of days), and wrote to apologize for not being able to accept the offer. Fifty years later, he had come to see some of the larger meaning of the words he and John Adams and the other members of the committee who had been charged to write the Delaration had put to paper.

He wrote:

“May it be to the world, what I believe it will be, (to some parts sooner, to others later, but finally to all,) the Signal of arousing men to burst the chains, under which monkish ignorance and superstition had persuaded them to bind themselves, and to assume the blessings & security of self-government. That form which we have substituted, restores the free right to the unbounded exercise of reason and freedom of opinion. All eyes are opened, or opening, to the rights of man. The general spread of the light of science has already laid open to every view the palpable truth, that the mass of mankind has not been born with saddles on their backs, nor a favored few booted and spurred, ready to ride them legitimately, by the grace of god. These are grounds of hope for others. For ourselves, let the annual return of this day forever refresh our recollections of these rights, and an undiminished devotion to them.”

So far, we have been able - with many delays and detours - to stick to that path. The greatest threat to that revolutionary dream stands tall around us today, which makes this Fourth of July one of the most important since the day the words “all men are created equal” were first heard. It’s our belief in that revolutionary dream that is why we are involved politically and socially as we are. We may not have achieved the ideal, we may never completely do so, but if we fail to stand for it now, it will be lost, possibly forever.

Expand full comment

Since the excerpt got such a nice respobnse (Thank you, thank you!) you could - if you want - read the whole thing (and some other things I've put up) over at: https://tcinla757.substack.com/p/the-revolutionary-dream

Expand full comment

TC has the pen in hand again! Love revival of his blog on Substack. It’s a complement to LFAA and a compliment to fine minds on this forum. Thank TC!

Happy 4th.

Expand full comment

TC Groupie heading on over to AFM!

Expand full comment

I did, and the whole piece is well worth the time. This is the antithesis of the entropy that CynthiaW discussed and will be the future of the country if enough of us actively live and support that dream.

Expand full comment

TC, thanks for sharing this. It is beautifully written, and says so, so much.

Expand full comment

Beautiful, TC. Thanks for sharing this. I especially liked what you wrote about how “they’ve come here, and by their coming every year, they keep the dream alive, because they arrive with it in their hearts.” Today is an emotional one for me.

Expand full comment

Thank you. This one sentence will bolster me through the dark times: "They’ve come here, and by their coming every year, they keep the dream alive, because they arrive with it in their hearts." I don't know what led my own ancestors here, but it is clear that they did arrive with a dream in their hearts and I'm here because of it and them.

Expand full comment

Really well done, thanks.

Expand full comment

Morning, TC!! And thank you.

Expand full comment

So true and very well said.

Expand full comment

Rhetoric. How many humans did Jefferson enslave. How many did he grant free before his death? In his will?

Expand full comment

Thank YOU TC!!!💕💓 And Happy Independence Day😊

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Jul 4, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Perhaps you might want to re-read the first paragraph of my post.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Jul 5, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

The U.S. immigration and border control department in the early 1900s classified people by Race of Irish, French, etc. Look for immigration records for your ancestors.

Expand full comment

Because not everyone is "with the program" now, any more than they were then.

Expand full comment

I was born in 1943 and grew up in what was then rural New Jersey. This was before the interstate highways and the 55 miles to New York took two and a half hours. New Jersey was almost as segregated as Mississippi with unwritten "rules" about where "colored" could eat or sit. The proposition of equality for women and those of different races and non-Christians was indeed open to question; one that would be decided upon on a case-by-case basis depending upon the way we "fit in" and met the expectations of our places in society. Could we strive and succeed financially? Yes, if we were careful. Could we join the golf club or swim in the public pool? No, that was asking too much but there was a lake down the road and a tree behind which one could change one's clothes. Things have changed, mostly for the better. As Dr. King said, "the arch of history bends towards justice." We are now in the midst of an American silly season. Here's to the hope that in the next year or two we will all be too busy and will ignore the grifter in chief and his henchmen.

Expand full comment

I too was born in 1943, and fully recall what you've described. I am Black and in the 60's, joined in the various protests on the then status quo of things: war, racism, poverty, general unfairness. The past four plus years brought me to near hopelessness and deep anger. However, millions of people rose to say "No!" to that period, and to assert that the principles of equality, fairness, access and diversity, across the spectrum, are still the values we'll fight for. And so, I'll continue marching on in this peculiar challenge that must be overcome.

Expand full comment

God bless you and keep you and your loved ones safe and well.

Expand full comment

Howard, I was born a generation later and also grew up in NJ, in a new (at the time) suburban community full of people, many at first military families whose dads were being shipped from Ft Dix and Maguire AFB to Vietnam, who were breaking out of the urban messes of Camden and Trenton for the first time. So I suspect roughly the same part of Jersey. I witnessed the slow transformation of the state from one that was split into three parts--the urban communities, the rural farmlands and Pine Barrens, and the coastal region--into a throbbing megalopolis linking NYC to Philadelphia. My great-grandfather, an immigrant who fled the pogroms of what is now Ukraine (it was the Russian Empire then), built the first big suburbs across the river from NYC--the "Oranges"--in the 1920s. Although he started as a bricklayer (a real mason!), with very little English and no real education, he pushed hard to create a career and fortune for himself and a future for his family, one that would have been impossible in Russia. His sons fought in the war, and one died on D-Day. At no time was this Jewish family welcomed by the WASP elite. He drank with his Irish and Italian employees, welcomed my father, a Greek-American, into the family (he, too, was shunned in college by the WASP elites and found friends in the Jewish fraternities and organizations), got the cold shoulder from the wannabe leaders of the synagogue he helped to build because he was too "ethnic" and too liberal in his politics.

So the fight goes on.

Expand full comment

What a lovely tribute to your father. The last part of it makes me sad while it makes me realize that even among those that are disallowed from "whitestream" society the discriminated against go on and discrimimnate against others. We see that in appalling clarity as the Israeli government does to the Palestinians what was done to them in WW2.

Expand full comment

That’s a lovely vignette of your father and your family’s story, Linda. A lot to be proud of, and such rich history there!

Expand full comment

Linda, your story sounds like mine. I grew up on Long Island, New York. My grandfather was also a bricklayer, (a real mason). He came to the US in 1913. He and my grandmother built a life that, according to my grandfather, they never could have had in Italy. They sent three of their five sons to fight in WWII, and their youngest son to Korea. They were proud to be citizens of this country, and said so frequently. Their grandchildren were successful. I’ve always been so proud of them.

Expand full comment

Linda and Howard: You know it's said that "you can take someone out of Jersey, but you can't take the Jersey out of them."

Expand full comment

Is it human nature to chose an enemy to fight and someone to dismiss? Groups that should be united to protect each other and blossom, break into splinters of wannabe winners.

Expand full comment

Some of us didn't get to choose our enemies. They chose us.

Expand full comment

One of those groups lined up with Vlad who wants to destroy us from the inside out, the other group just wants peace and love for everyone. The ones choosing peace and love just want Vlad’s group to stop obstructing progress towards peace and love and a verdant life with their lies and thievery

Expand full comment

This is the wealth, the richness of America.

Expand full comment

An apt time to reprise the entire quote which, being a theologian, Dr. King used and which is attributed to him. They are the words of the humanist theologian Theodore Parker:

"I do not pretend to understand the moral universe; the arc is a long one, my eye reaches but little ways; I cannot calculate the curve and complete the figure by the experience of sight; I can divine it by conscience. And from what I see I am sure it bends towards justice."

A century later, attributed to Martin Luther King Jr.

Expand full comment

I also appreciate Eric Holder's amendment to Theodore Parker's quote:

"the arc...only bends toward justice because people pull it towards justice."

Expand full comment

Is this the same Theodore Parker who said, “Southern Slavery is an institution that is in earnest. Northern Freedom is an institution that is not in earnest.”? This to me is the most provocative quote of the pre-civil war era.

Expand full comment

Yes - he was an abolitionist, transcendentalist and all-around brilliant, fascinating man. Abraham Lincoln used his "of the people, by the people, for the people." Parker was one of the first women's suffragists and the first to name God father and mother.

Expand full comment

I am not familiar with T. Parker, but I think he was pointing to the Southern willingness to kill and die to have free. forced labor forever. The Northern conscience was not as firm about eliminating free, forced labor because the profit margin looked better without wages.

Expand full comment

Again, I suggest reading about Theodore Parker. He was an abolitionist and much more. He also held Christian exceptionalism up to a critical light, for example.

Expand full comment

An interesting and courageous, if complex, character (but then, simple characters tend to be signs of simple minds, IMO): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodore_Parker

Expand full comment

"the profit margin looked better without wages." Um...wasn't that the whole reason the South wanted slavery forever? Their entire economy was based on it. The Northern economy wasn't.

Expand full comment

I’m so confused?

Expand full comment

Why confused? Just look up Theodore Parker. He was a theologian and an abolitionist who had a profound influence on the future path of the Unitarian Universalist church. His critique of church in general led him to disavow the institution as Christianity was/is seen. If you happen to be around West Roxbury, Mass, you can visit the Theodore Parker Unitarian Church.

Expand full comment

Spend 7 minutes with descendants of Frederick Douglass on the Fourth of July:

“At a time like this, scorching irony not convincing argument is needed. Oh, had I, the ability, and could I reach the nation’s ear, I would today pour out a fiery steam of biting ridicule, blasting reproach, withering sarcasm, and stern rebuke. For it is not light that is needed, but fire. It is not the gentle shower, but thunder. We need the storm. The feeling of the nation must be quickened. And the conscience of the nation must be roused. The propriety of the nation must be startled. The hypocrisy of the nation must be exposed and its crimes against God and man must be denounced.”

https://www.npr.org/2020/07/03/884832594/video-frederick-douglass-descendants-read-his-fourth-of-july-speech

and you can read it for yourself:

https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/what-to-the-slave-is-the-4th-of-july-speech-transcript-by-frederick-douglass

Expand full comment

Mr. Douglass spoke at rallies just a few miles from where we live. I take folks on URR tours due to so many locations that were stations on the URR hosted by area Quakers. Possibly over 2,000 self-emancipated people passed through here. Yet, it's so important to read William Still's book, "The Underground Railroad: Authentic Narratives and First-Hand Accounts" to understand that Black folks assisted way more self-emancipated people than did the Quakers. The Society of Friends (Quakers) did own human beings early on, yet they decided it was so wrong that they changed their ways. They visited fellow Quakers who still enslaved people and some were made to leave the Society over that. It always makes me think of Maya Angelou's often quoted saying that when they knew better, they did better. May we all be like that.

Expand full comment

Carla, what good work you are doing. In what state?

Expand full comment

Thanks, Ellie. Pennsylvania which surrounds us with history. The State legislature is controlled by Republicans, but we do have Governor Wolf who is a Democrat and the admirable Lt. Gov. John Fetterman. Lots of work ahead of us.

Expand full comment

Yes, Ellie, more clearly stated than I did above. Thank you, and all those who persist.

Expand full comment

Cathy Mc., IMHO you are too humble!

Expand full comment

Perfect, just perfect, Ellie. Thank you for this. I listened to The Rachel Maddow show the other day about how Frederick Douglas was sent to Mount Misery (the property that Donald Rumsfeld bought later on), a place singularly designed to “break” slaves. Douglas was sent there by his “owner”for a year, I believe, because he had too much spirit. He was whipped and tortured and worked nearly to death, and in his writings he speaks about being, indeed, nearly broken mentally and physically, his soul tormented. But he miraculously survived intact and went on to become one of our most distinguished leaders. What he endured and what he modeled for us, with his eloquent and stirring words, are the perfect allegory for us today. In a way, it feels as if we, as a nation, are in a kind of slumber and need to be awakened, and quick. We need a Frederick Douglas to travel the country, speaking and rousing us to action. His impassioned words are just as relevant and must be heeded in this moment.

Expand full comment

And, once again, there is so much history and relevance about our Black brothers and sisters that we know little about.

Expand full comment

"We need a Frederick Douglas to travel the country, speaking and rousing us to action."

"We" could be Frederick Douglass, and work toward the change we want to see and be.

Those who did not survive Mount Misery and similar insitutions and practices mentally, physically, or spiritually, deserve commemoration.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Pam. I did not know about Mount Misery and Frederick Douglass' suffering and endurance there that was beyond the "normal" experience of enslaved people.

Frederick Douglass does continue to speak as we relay his writings and experience via social media.

Expand full comment