Family members, friends, and political leaders gathered today at the Washington National Cathedral to honor the life of former president Jimmy Carter, who died on December 29 at age 100.
As I watched Jimmy Carter’s service in Washington, I was profoundly moved. One doesn’t necessarily shed grieving tears for a rare and special man who filled his century on earth with extraordinary accomplishments…none greater than simply and so naturally modeling how to well live one’s life.
My tears tonight were mixed; most were those welling from heartfelt gratitude for - and celebration of - his countless and lifelong examples of pure, native decency and grace.
My other tears were the ones of actual mourning…grief for the current deviation in the moral compass of so many in this country. Through an imperfect storm of fear, ignorance and malignancy, 75 millionAmericans elected to empower hate with safe harbor, as was pointedly referenced from the national cathedral’s pulpit today.
But I believe – and I am bedrock certain that Jimmy Carter would have us all understand, and believe in our hearts – that there is absolutely more goodness than bad in this world. He led a life that demonstrated how each and every one of us must - repeat “must”- pitch in, lend a hand (with or without a hammer in it), BE the Light and share that Light.
“Power and title,” as also referenced today, are not at all the answer. “Do unto others…” is.
I’ll vote for that as long as I can. Thank you Jimmy and Rosalyn.
Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood's simple, yet simply gorgeous, rendition of Imagine was oh so appropriate. I cried hearing it. I've long said that John Lennon's beautiful ode to the planet, and to humanity, should be our national anthem. Jimmy Carter lived that song his entire long life.
His choice of music was just perfect, particularly the entrance piece, The Road Home by Stephen Paulus, and makes me cry every time I hear it. He was welcomed home by Rosalyn and is at peace. He gave us so much and yesterday reminded us of just what that was. Now it is ours to continue in his honor.
I feel certain that God said to Jimmy Carter, “Well done, good and faithful servant. Welcome home.” What a powerful example Jimmy Carter was of living one’s faith.
Yes he did. That song tugs at my heart and I offer it whenever a loved one leaves us. It is so poignant. I also had the good fortune to have a son who sang in a men's chorus in college, and while they never sang this particular piece, they did many very similar works. Just beautiful balm for the soul at times like these.
Harvey, "Imagine" was our class song in 1973. I recall not voting for it (I was clearly a stupid graduate) and can't remember what I did vote for, but Lennon's beautiful anthem of peace and brotherhood was indeed the best choice for then as well as today and tomorrow.
Donny was fighting every instink to try to be the center of attention…watching him fidgeting when they were standing to leave was actually funny! Such a little boy!
Thank you, Ron, for the link. I loved hearing it yesterday and it still brings tears today. Has always been my favorite song, too. Garth and Yearwood's rendition is simply lovely.
How does one resolve the apparent conflict between a tribute to a person of faith with a song promoting “no heaven and no religion” ideas? By recognizing that real religion involves making heaven on Earth by repeatedly strengthening the bonds that keep us from thinking it’s “us” against “them” (“re” = redo and “ligion” = ligament = binding), while also recognizing that the phrase “no phony religion” in a beautiful song would sound discordant.
My take away from Carter requesting John Lennon's song Imagine, is that while Carter was a Christian of deep faith...he saw that it's not the only way. There are a number of faith traditions across the planet and that if we are to get to the goal of peace, we have to respect each other...and love each other, no matter the details of our faith. I believe the line that matters the most is that "we live as one".
James, faith does not require adherence to a religious doctrine. It may be nice if the two converge, but for many, they do not. In the case of Christians, faith in Jesus Christ can stand alone, without the discordance organized religion brings.
I agree, but a religious practice is the application of a religious tradition’s founding principles. Without those principles, you don’t have a faith or a religion. With those principles, you do have a faith that is independent of context, and then you need to understand how to apply the principles in specific contexts, which is when a religious practice inevitably emerges.
You are correct in saying that faith in Jesus Christ can stand alone without the discordance organized religions bring, but there’s only one reason why organized religions bring discordance, and that reason is when a religious institution starts disregarding their tradition’s founding principles.
For the record, the two Christian principles are stated by Jesus several times throughout the four Gospels including in Matthew 22:34-40. Everything else is a context-specific application of, or a context-specific disregard for, those two context-independent principles.
Yes! Grace in the line of fire! It always reminds me of harm ‘Religion’ creates when we replace truth with power over others, particularly females! Preaching, screeching hate is not supposed to be the found of the God of love! Stop them before they get a handmaid on the Supreme Court!
President Carter's accomplishments post Presidency exemplify what an amazing man he was. For someone that has not been President for 45 years, it is amazing to see the genuine love and respect from so many people who were touched by perhaps the greatest humanitarian ever.
And Rosalyn, redefined the role of First Lady participating during his Presidency and long after, like no other First Lady except perhaps Eleanor Roosevelt.
The music documentary of Duane Allman reminds us of Carter's love of music and how much musicians thought of him. The Allman brothers were in their early 20's and were all-in on Jimmy Carter.
Jimmy Carter was a person of true faith. He understood that you don’t just hope for the best or prepare for the worst. You do what you can to make the world a better place, and his life proved that he was right. Now he’s left that legacy for us to follow.
Personally, I think it's true that the good die young based on my definition of old. To me, when a person thinks they know everything, and they're always right, they're old regardless of their chronological age. By that definition, Jimmy Carter died young. As for me, I hope I die before I get old.
James, nicely put. I am actually old in years, but I hope that I can keep realizing how much I do not know and continue learning as i do from so many who post here. I thought the eulogies were on point as a tribute to Carter and also a pointed reference in some cases to death star.
Trae Crowder, a comedian who calls himself the “liberal redneck” (and is worth following), said “Jimmy Carter, who died at the age of 100, or, as the Democrats would say, in the prime of his life …” Touché, especially with 91-year-old Chuck Grassley third in line to the throne… oops, I meant the presidency (sorry Chief Roberts).
I tend to believe the scheduling conflict, as she always says to go high. And I do think she would have given him a look that would have shriveled the mushroom.
If the OM squirmed, that would suggest (1) that he understood what he was hearing, and (2) that he has enough self-awareness to realize the contrast. I doubt it. OTOH, it might have meant that his girdle was too tight. That I could believe.
When GWB was in office, I thought he was an absolute idiot. I'm still not very fond of him, but a year or so ago, I read something that redeemed him somewhat. I've recommended this book on this forum often" "Shall We Wake the President: Two Centuries of Disaster Management from the Oval Office" by Tevi Troy.
Apparently, while in office, Bush read about the 1918 Flu and was so concerned that he took some action! I am very concerned that should another pandemic happen under Trump Part Two that this world would not get off as "easy" as it did with COVID. I think a great percentage of the populace absolutely will not wear masks, take a vaccine, etc.
Unfortunately, in today's America, there is more bad than good, as evidenced by a plurality of citizens who voted for Trump to return to the White House to continue his evil and chaotic ways. We, collectively, cannot say "That's not who we are." Elections have consequences.
Yes, there is no Trump mandate.Also people did not sign off of what he is pushing.No one voted for annexing Canadá and invading Greenland not even the rubes who voted for him.There was no mention in the Republican platform of taking over the Panama Canal and renaming it.This is the stuff of a madman and I and others won’t buy any of it. Smh
It's a distraction while he robs the country and supports billionaires and dictators in lining their already full to bursting pockets. His only goals are staying out of jail and stealing as much of the country's wealth as he can.
Distraction, smokescreen, gaslighting, call it what you will. He throws this stuff out to rile up others while he continues on his plunder. But we cannot take anything this madman says as pure jest. He is like a loose cannon and it is hard to tell where he is going with a lot of this bs, be it a"distraction" or no. Germans did not take Hitler seriously until it was too late.
I had the pleasure of listening to Simon Rosenberg and Hopium yesterday. He pointedly says not to just brush off his rantings as distractions, Trump just being Trump. The president of the US is a powerful position and his proclamations have ramifications, no matter how harebrained they may seem. We need to hold him and his administration accountable for the things they say, and so does our media, as weak-kneed as it is these days.
Yes, the media is weak-kneed but Meidas is fighting the good fight against MAGA disinfo!
“Anyway, I posted the Trump screenshot, and in ALL CAPS (because we know that’s how MAGA prefers to communicate), I wrote:
WAKE UP! ALL OF THIS IS TO DISTRACT YOU! PRICES ARE NOT GETTING LOWER. HOUSING IS NOT BEING SOLVED. THERE IS NO UKRAINE PEACE DEAL. HE IS A WEAPON OF MASS DISTRACTION. DO NOT FALL FOR IT AGAIN!!
Here’s the post, which has been viewed over 1.2 million times in 48 hours (mostly by my target audience: MAGA).”
From what I understand MAGA is not happy. These oligarchs actually want to import immigrants, raise the debt ceiling to accommodate their outlandish increases and immigrants themselves. (all stuff MAGA hates)
Thank you Barbara, you provided about the same answer I would have. …there’s the number of registered voters (approximately a third) who just do not participate in or fulfill one of the few - but most important civic duties - that of educating themselves, if not at least once every two years, once every four years and participating in our wonderful society by VOTING. …and then there is that significant number of those who voted for Biden/Harris in 2020, who did not seem to vote in the 2024 election. What happened to or where were they?
We - Democrats and…along with other wise, sane and smart Americans [yes, most Democrats do seem to be smart, sane and wise] - have to mobilize like minded individuals to fulfill their civic duty in 2026 and the Party needs to use/spend/invest the monies they solicit and receive smartly and wisely [it’s sometimes referred to as being prudent] and help find and motivate some superb democratic candidates to run for local, state and national positions. The handwriting is on the wall, the Democrats must have as one of their top objectives after the 2028 election: increasing the size of the Supreme Court!
I agree most Americans are good people who want peace and prosperity in their lives. The 15 million missing voters haunts me. I can't shake the gut feeling there was some dark fooling around with ballots.
Jim, I've been pounding this issue for quite some time. More people did not vote than voted for either Harris or TCF (now in capitals, because he will be sentenced today).
I can't assume that. The political climate in America is so corrupted and chaotic right now. The propaganda machine has been at work for many years. Too many Americans think up is down. Also. Gerrymandering and voter suppression have taken their toll.
What does disturb me is the deliberate choice people made to vote for someone they know in their heart is evil and a clear and present danger to our Democratic way of life. That hurts.
Thank you. "Save Our Democracy!" is the rallying cry these days, but "our democracy" was in real trouble before Trump was elected the first time but many people -- primarily white middle-class-and-up straight people, I suspect -- didn't realize it and weren't already fighting (and voting) to make it better.
I've never been in the "If you don't vote, you can't complain" camp. Some people who don't vote have a better understanding of the situation than many of those who do vote. I take the existence of non-voters and even Trump voters as a challenge to those of us to vote in every election, from the most local to the presidential. We need to make the connections clearer between "government" and our daily lives. And we need to hold our elected officials accountable.
I general I think people are more "good" than bad, but bad has a practical advantage as it can ride on entropy. It's so much easier to bully than liberate. So much easier to destroy than build something worthwhile. Though ugliness gets old at some point.
J L--I don't think quantifying "bad" vs "good" has any practical purpose. Doesn't matter how many good people there are if they are not engaged in the process. And being engaged takes work. And yes, as you note, hate is easier than love--or even "like."
Or even tolerance.
Love takes work, attention, selflessness . . .
And when the two are competing, "bad" definitely has the advantages of being ignited by hate, sustained by ignorance, and "riding on entropy,"* in its inexorable trajectory of destruction. Tragically, once it "gets old," who will be able to do anything about it?
_____________________________
*Your phrase, "riding on entropy" is so poetic, it ironically evoked dark alternate lyrics for "Walking in Rhythm":
“At our best,” Biden said, “we share the better parts of ourselves: joy, solidarity, love, commitment. Not for reward, but in reverence for the incredible gift of life we’ve all been granted. To make every minute of our time here on Earth count.” “That’s the definition of a good life,” Biden said. It was the life Jimmy Carter lived for 100 years: a “good life of purpose and meaning, of character driven by destiny and filled with the power of faith, hope, and love.”
Many disagree with my including President Ford as one of the two best Presidents, right along there with President Carter. President Carter and President Ford exchanged pre-written eulogies for their eventual funerals. Those dueling eulogies deepen my conviction that two men of impeccable characters and divergent politics really can like and esteem the best each sees in the other.
Oregon had the same treat with Gordon Smith (R) and Ron Wyden (D) as our Oregon senators in the early 2000's. They walked into the Senate chamber every morning, side by side, shook hands, and went to their respective "sides". Both worked, first and foremost, for Oregon.
Thank you for your eloquent and heartfelt remarks. They inspired me to repost my reply to Substack’s Civil Discourse with Joyce Vance:
"Jimmy Carter seems to have timed his death to send the country a much needed message."
He couldn't have timed it better for another reason. It could not have been just me listening to eulogy after eulogy praising President Carter's stellar character and not think of the spectacular contrast to that of the scumbag who will reoccupy the WH.
I will forever treasure meeting President Carter and our correspondence. He told me that he never felt any conflict between his scientific background and his faith. He had the kIndest face I've ever seen. I sent him my first book, not knowing if he would bother reading it. Not only did he read it but he sent me an incredibly thoughtful letter about how much he enjoyed it and went on to encourage my writing. I believe that he was the closest thing to Jesus on this earth. I brought it to his attention that they even shared the same initials....
Peter, I regret I could only give Professor Richardson one ❤️ for today’s letter and I regret I can only give you one ❤️ for this comment. Well said, thank you.
I loved Carter’s grandson’s story of how he would make pancakes and how he made a cradle with his own hands for any one of his grandchildren. The best, however, came from Joe Biden when he spoke about the dignity and respect Jimmy Carter gave everyone, no matter who they were. When Biden was speaking, he glared right at Donald who was squirming in his seat like a child who is bored. Melania never smiled or made any expression. This is what we get to look forward to.
I was going to comment about the “hand over heart” gesture that everyone else made except the felon-in-chief, but this is about the character of dear President Carter, who truly earned the honorary title forevermore. Rest in peace, sir.
I watched him as the Flag went past, when it was already gone, he finally put his hand over his Stomach. Must not have learned too much in his previous 4 years in office.
Susan, that is what I call the "ballpark salute" where caps (on the occasion that they are worn) are removed and placed on the stomach, rather than the correct position, with the hand over the heart.
When the US National Colors are presented in a procession, uniformed personnel should render the military salute (right hand to right eyebrow). All citizens should render the hand salute, which is the right hand held over the heart; if a cover (hat) is worn and not part of a uniform, it should be removed and positioned at or above the left shoulder so the hand remains over the heart. As the presentation passes, the salute is slowly released. Remain standing until directed to sit.
Yes, and today, Trump has to go before Judge Merchon to receive his sentence for campaign finance violations. I hope, even if it’s a flutter, that he realizes how out of his depth he is at leading this nation.
It affects the Trump organization’s dealings in NY. It also changes his travel status - countries would have to make exceptions to allow a felon to enter their country.
Read the Frozen River. Takes place in the late 1700s. A rich and powerful judge commits rapes and was told to spend time at home (don't leave the country type of thing), but he flees the county, but does show up for court. Of course, he was found innocent by a jury of all men He then resumes his judge position. Does this sound familiar?
Yet, all I saw yesterday was how Michelle Obama missed the service and how Mrs. Pence ignored trump ( I didn't know about the Bush snub) and Kamala looked at trump. Of yes, one person must have not read or just watched the clip of Kamala looking at trump and made the comment that Biden wasn't there! It goes to show you how a cherry picked snippet influences gullible people.
I've been occupied by watching the evolving consequences of the urban wildfires in an area we left because of ever increasing heat wave extremes in both maximum heat and duration of long dry spells, combined with periods of heavier rainfall in shorter periods that cause floods that exceed the mitigation efforts designed for older climate conditions.
Apparently, as of yesterday, 16 families that our family's friends in Pasadena know, may have lost their homes in Altadena. I do know at least the auditorium of the Eliot Middle School was on fire in a little pocket in the larger area of the southern edge of a much larger area. I had attended a lot of Pasadena IBM User Group (PIBMUG) meeting there during the dozen years I worked in Pasadena. PIBMUG earlier meetings had started at Caltech with some interesting guest speakers. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p7KQibWUDcM
I don't remember exactly where Steve Bass live(d/s) but I believe it was in the Eaton fire burned (or evacuation area if he lived in Pasadena. Part of Steve's author's bio on Amazon:
"...I first learned about computers in 1982 with an IBM PC I bought from Computerland. When I asked them for support, they said, "Don't use it in the shower."
The following day, I founded the Pasadena IBM Users Group. After 24 years, I finally closed the organization, releasing the over 2,400 former members onto the streets (http://www.pibmug.com). Be careful out there. And in the late 1980s, I co-founded the Association of Personal Computer User Groups (http://www.apcug.org), a nationwide organization serving user groups..."
Then there is one of my favorite Data Scientists who(while working with Caltech, I assume) left a future Nobel Prize winning team (for their LIGO work and I'd seen when later visiting the Hanford LIGO site), to take up the climate data challenges at JPL. I don't know if he still lives about 3 miles from JPL but I ran across the following article that describes how he and his family felt during the Bobcat Fire that threatened the area for months in 2020.
I'm no where near as smart or dedicated as Peter, but I have a strong dose of concern for what he sees as some of the best data and analysis of the trouble we are facing if we don't redouble or triple our efforts to limit climate heating. Last I knew he was living within 3 miles of JPL and at least in the evacuation zone.
Big Oil may deny what they really know about climate change costs, but I have to believe the Insurance Companies losses will make insurance impossible to provide at affordable prices. How can anyone imagine trying to replace all that is being lost already, much less how much more will be lost if no changes are made?
Seems to me that abuse of power is humanity's most tragic and dangerous, perhaps fatal flaw. We have met the enemy and he is us. Can we learn from past mistakes before it's too late?
God I hope we are given Guidance to step away from misleading misanthropes who are multiplying around the doors into the Oval Office. I am also working now, because of the humane gifts from Jimmy Carter’s funeral service today, to turn my prayers to light and connection with my neighbors and coworkers in every encounter hence forward.
Fear is not a comfortable feeling. Whatever is coming will be met best with every effort to connect, exchange plans to deal with our challenges and create safety for all.
I’m so pleased I had the opportunity to ‘attend’ the whole funeral service on the internet today.
We might have been far better off keeping Carter, but I was a junior in high school and had concerns about Reagan. Carter was almost universally reviled then, but he told us what we needed to hear. Reagan told many people what they wanted to hear while laying the groundwork for our current mess.
I was busy doing family things and didn't even turn the television on or search for it on the Internet, but I'm going to make time to watch President Carter's entire funeral. Somehow I know I'm going to be inspired by it. Something you said clicked, and I asked myself, how can I make America a better place other than voting? And it occurred to me that in order to help my community I need to connect more with my neighbors. To be honest I've always left the vast majority of that to my wife. It's time for me to get more involved. I may be old, but I can still learn a few more tricks.
Same here, Justin. I have a free day today (except for taking the cat to the vet. Stupid Orange Boy, yet again...) and would like to watch it in its entirety.
Inattentive is a kind way to describe him. Whenever the camera panned around to the row of presidents. he looked either asleep or unconscious. Or daydreaming, about goodness knows what. But thoroughly unengaged. The antithesis to President Carter and the gravity of the Oval Office.
When President Carter worked on building houses with Habitat, he got his hands dirty. When he worked the peanut fields, he got his hands dirty. When he went to impoverished countries to help monitor elections and spread health initiatives, he got his hands dirty. As dirty as his hands got, his ideals were about as clean and pure as any person. Juxtaposing Carter’s funeral with Trump’s inauguration obviates how low our standards have become.
Phil, I have posted this here a few times, but never know who sees it, so will post again….one of my favorite poems “To Be of Use” by Marge Piercy, to me it describes those who just do the right thing….because it’s the right thing to do: https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/57673/to-be-of-use Jimmy Carter was the first president I was eligible (21 was the age limit then) to vote for…and did so twice & very sad he didn’t win reelection—I mean you could tell he was an agent of positive change! Highest praise: He was a good man. Although I am not at all a deist or religious, I will say Amen to that!
Hello Barbara... Thanks for illustrating how Jimmy Carter put his Post-Presidency to use furthering Humankind... Contrast this Service with how DJT has put his Post-Nov 5 2020 time to use, and where DJT has spent it...
Yeah, Apache, building up versus tearing down….they could not be more opposite in character/actions. I hope his example and his & Rosalynn’s actions serve as an example to all, especially to our youth who are/will be stepping up to lead
It seems to me rather unprecedented that the Republicans would follow the dictates of an ex-president and now his megalomaniac backroads on how and what to vote for, yet this is where we are.
Jimmy Carter was the antithesis of a Southerner MAGA. He loved everyone. They hate everyone. He was progressive. They are regressive.
Change is hard and change is usually good, but Project 2025 is not good change. Project 2025 is not conservative, it is regressive and who we were in the past is not worth returning to.
Barbara, the year was 1972 when 18-year-olds were allowed to vote: I know this because I was 18 that year and was able to vote for Joe Biden as Delaware’s Democrat Senator. I’m a born and raised Delawarean and stood about 10 feet in front of him and his late wife Neilia at a Democratic rally at Christiana High School (Newark, DE) days before the 1972 election. He was our first Democrat Senator in my then young life and we were hopeful that things would change that year, but unfortunately, many changes were not for the better in so many ways (Mrs. Biden and their daughter would die the next month and Nixon won another term). It’s a memory that will always be happy and sad for me. I volunteer for the League of Women Voters and we go to high schools and register 17-1/2 and 18-year-olds to vote and I tell young people that I was the first generation of 18-year-olds who would eligible to vote—they don’t know that the voting age was changed from 21 because it’s been this way for over 50 years—we take it for granted. I also tell them that the 18-year-olds did not make a difference in 1972 national election because they didn’t vote in significant numbers (low turnout) and I encourage young people that they are our future and can make a difference. Perhaps they will understand in 2028?
Also, Jimmy Carter has been the only President that I’ve ever been able to shake hands with—he jumped the lines that separated us from him (as he was known to do!) and made his way to greet the crowd waiting to get a chance to see him exit from attending an speaking event in Columbia, MO when he was then President! The Secret Service guys moved at the speed of light to get to him! Bless him and his family and loved ones ☮️💟
Linda, I, too, voted for the first time in a midterm election (1975 for me) and it is hard to reconcile the breezy dismissal of the importance of voting that happens nowadays with the struggles we had to get the voting age lowered to 18. Carter was the first presidential candidate I was able to vote for. I very much wish he had been a better campaigner who could have tanked Reagan's steamroller but his commitment to integrity, truth, and reality ran counter to the fantasies of most Americans--long before the current Disinformation Media Flood--and was a scary sign of things to come.
Thank you for posting the poem. It makes one think about what is truly important in life. We need more helpers and fewer destroyers. Trump, I'm looking at you.
Barbara, thanks for the poetry link. What a lovely thought to start the day. Enjoyed listening to the funeral on the way to an appointment and happy to hear it continuing when the appointment finished. It was a heartfelt and fitting tribute to a wonderful man. The world needs more like him.
Since I am late on the forum, you might not see the link I am posting today. Our beloved HCR in a 42 minute interview, two days ago on the Meidas Network youtube channel "Politics Girl". So worth the time!
...and you are one to give of yourself by sharing this powerful poem with us (even I, an "old folk" am encouraged)....there are ways even I can give....
This is my first reading of this poem and it is beautiful, as it is also inspiring. I love it. Thank you. You shared at the right time for the right occasion.
Barbara, Carter was the first president I voted for as well. I turned 18 in 1976, and was able to vote in Oregon's primary that May. It was ratified in 1971, and I believe that 1972 was the first presidential election that was impacted by it.
I note with pride that the case was Mitchell v. Oregon.
Agreed. I think it was part of one of the most fundamental of Christian values that Carter practiced, which is humility. You might be the son of God, you still wash your disciples' feet.
When his grandson told the story of his grandfather calling him I laughed through my tears. I’m not calling you. I’m taking a picture. Thank you President Carter for your selfless service to our county.
If I had to rate them, I would say Jason Carter's eulogy was the best. He honored our tears and provided us a reason to laugh/smile for our 39th President.
They were all excellent, with Jason Carter's and President Biden's perhaps the most memorable for me, but Andrew Young's homily was deeply moving, when he said Jimmy Carter "had a tough mind and a tender heart" and "symbolized the greatness of America." I feel that Carter's memorial service from beginning to end was like a long and beautiful meditation on heart and spirit.
I found it grotesque to see Trump there on the eve of his sentencing, eyes closed like a dozing reptile, surrounded by former presidents and vice presidents, all of whom at least understood the immense responsibility of the job and their oath to uphold the constitution. And Hillary and Kamala, the women he verbally assaulted to defeat them, having to sit just a few feet away, as if none of it had ever happened.
He is the antithesis everything Jimmy Carter was, in all things.
I felt the exact opposite. He sat there squiring, uncomfortable and afraid to be in the company of goodness. He was shunted to the side in the second row and had to listen to good people talk of character. I saw a symbol in the videos. He was outnumbered by the good people. Our ancestors Washington, Hamilton, MLK, JFK, Mondale, Rosa Parks, and all our historical and memorable voices of freedom and patriotism showed up in the Cathedral yesterday. They reminded us we will be ok. We need to fight like they did.
And there he was, sitting at the end of the row, stewing in his hatred while his wife stewed in hers. Each word spoken came from a mouth he cannot wait to spike onto his nailhead of loathing. That box, that casket casting its cold breath of mortality across the orange leather of his skin, infuriating under that honored flag that should fly at full mast every day since his glorious exaltation back to the presidency. There will be no half-mast come January 21. No hands to the heart, no pledge to decency or character. Just his half-closed eyes envisioning them all cast into the Hell he cannot wait to unleash upon the earth.
I think it might be more appropriate to refer to Melania as Donald's escort. I'm pretty sure she stopped being his wife some 18 years ago. These days, her public appearances with Donald are limited to those specified and compensated according to a contractual agreement. When "off the clock," she's a cougar on the prowl.
I found Andrew Young’s remarks particularly poignant, but it was President Carter’s grandson Jason Carter who brought it home for me. These two men, who knew Jimmy Carter so well, defined him as a man whose moral compass was always true: I couldn't agree more.
It was difficult watching the service – catching occasional glimpses of DJT who is the living antithesis of everything Jimmy Carter represented.
When isn’t he scowling? When isn’t he lying? Trump is telling the truth about how he wants to be a dictator, and about the nasty things he plans to do. I think he won’t leave office.
I "liked" your comment .......................I also believe that anyone who thinks
Trump will leave the Presidency in 4 years is out of their minds. Reality has been slapping us in the face more and more since he left his first catastrophic term!!! We have been made aware of his convictions and yet we ignore the reality of losing freedoms we have gained due to the spilt blood of American patriots. Trump calls these patriots, "losers".
Our laws are not holding back a tyrant and not even "in and of himself" a capable tyrant. I say once again, he is a willing puppet being placed in a position of power by his puppeteers. He is just basking in power. He loves the attention! The hungry wolves lusting after money and power are close on his heels! He is THEIR pathway to power!!!
Thank you President Biden for your decency and leadership and faith!
I only wish we had given Netanyahu NOTHING until the hostages were brought home. By making the choice to send weapons, we gave him power to rip apart the lives of innocent and helpless people in the Middle East including citizens in Israel and to build up more poverty....take away education opportunities for thousands of children, and to increase hatred against America.
Thank you Jimmy Carter!!! May you rest in peace. We need more like you.
Agreed - the contrast could not have been more striking. The “love and respect” with which Jimmy Carter met the world and lived his life are not in Trump’s vocabulary or world view.
Elegant, insightful. Thanks for this. But a thought hovered over it all ... one more helicopter and we never get Reagan. What would our world look like with another four years with Carter?
What would our word look like with 4 years (or more) of Al Gore, instead of Bush Jr? Just think of the progress that would have been made toward addressing climate change.
What would our world look like with 4 years (or more) of Hillary Clinton, instead of Trump? Just think if Putin would not have been emboldened to invade Ukraine, and how the US would have addressed the pandemic from a position of medical knowledge, and how white supremacists would not have been emboldened as they were under Trump, etc, etc.
"While Obama, sitting next to Trump, spoke to him, former president Bush refused to acknowledge Trump, instead walking past him and giving a familiar greeting to Obama."... Even though none of the Bushes gave endorsements in the last Election. at least GWB seems to acknowledge how bad DJT is... I also saw a clip of DJT glaring at Karmala... I hope that DJT doesn't make her Public Enemy #1... Finally some Good News out of the Supreme Court Today... DJT's Appeal to delay his NYC Sentencing was DENIED.... Maybe the Walls-Are-Starting-To-Close-In on DJT.... In Addiction, part of Jack Smith's Mar-a-Lago Stolen Classified Documents Report will be released... More Good News...
Former President Obama is much more dignified than the Orange Menace, but the Orange Menace threw shade on the former president every chance hegot. Ta-Nehisi Coates, who is one the best writers of our time, notes we got Trump precisely because of electing Obama.
I have thought for a long time that this is the backlash for electing a black president. And one as articulate and compassionate, accomplished and unflappable as Obama is, makes some people in this country all the more angry. I just don't get how they can hold on to all that animosity, and then vote to throw everything away based on it.
I always felt then - and certainly now, as probably Biden regrettably feels - that it should have been, if not a Biden/Hillary ticket, Biden along with someone, that was offered up to the American voters in the 2016 presidential election!
Yes, he will have the title of felon, but without any consequences. He will still rule with a heavy hand, spew lies and hate, and do as he pleases. One thing he will never have is the title of A Good Man.
We should be concerned about Trump's manipulation of SCOTUS. Look at the many terrible decisions they have handed down since Trump left office.
And they have used Trump (and Cohn's) delay tactic to delay decisions involving Trump. What other citizen could petition SCOTUS to have them intervene in a personal Federal case? Trump and his billionaire buddies are truly above the law.
I thought he was trying to bully her. It felt like it did on the stage with H. Clinton at the debate. VP Harris and her husband looked in all kinds of pain (so sad to see.) I was also concerned for the Bidens. They looked grim and frail.
I was pleased at the Bush maneuver but surprised at Obama. Can you explain what Obama was up to being so friendly?
It has been said that Trump’s motivation to run for President was inspired by Obama’s comments about him during the 2015 Correspondents dinner/roast…Call it up on YouTube and watch Trump really squirm…
One can never really know where the path not taken would led, but before Reagan, Carter and even Nixon favored environmental protection. I wonder where we would be had unbroken efforts continued.
Yeah, Arthur, the big “what if”! I voted for him (2nd time) to be re-elected and was sorely disappointed when he didn’t win…such a lost opportunity. Same, too, as others here have commented on Gore’s (questionable) loss. Dunno, perhaps somewhere in this massive Universe there is an alternative reality playing out…would be interesting to see IF such a path made any consequential differences. Guess we’ll never know!
Much of history turns on what, in retrospect, are flukes. The ones that we find compelling are those that had significant implications. There were, are, will be -- must be -- innumerable others that weren't significant because, well ... because they weren't. I'm not trying to be obtuse here ... just probabilistic. Consider where we'd be today if the bullet that pierced Trump's ear was two inches to the left.....
I believe there is an infinite number of alternate realities; it’s just this one where our consciousness resides. And it’s really, really hard to be positive when things are so badly mangled.
Beautifully told How strange that we are going from the passing of Carter such a honorable man and president so close to the day that his exact opposite is supposed to be “sworn “ in A good man who loved his neighbor to the exact opposite Someone who told the truth and followed the constitution to…. Someone who did good to…. So unbelievable and tragic for this country
I was not thinking of blue, white and red hats with golden letters and not even a slogan, my intention was to point to a goal at the end of the tunnel. After your reply I understand some people would adopt it as slogan. Point well taken Barbara.
Thank you, Dr. Richardson. I have always admired President Carter as a human being and as the only living Christian I've ever heard of. While I don't share his belief, I deeply respect and admire him.
Like our current President, Joe Biden, Jimmy Carter accomplished far more in his four years of the Presidency than he was ever given credit for. It wasn't until he died that I learned all his wonderful accomplishments. I had the pleasure of working on helping to build a couple of homes in his Habitat for Humanity - what a marvelous gift that was both for the givers and the receivers. I'm proud that I voted for Jimmy Carter in 1976 and 1980.
As a young Argentinian living Buenos Aires at that time in the middle of a bloody military dictatorship ,President Carter and his active defense of human rights was the only hope we had and actually save hundreds of young people's lives. Thanks MrPresident .Eternity .
Where will we find that person? Where will we find such bravery...such goodness...such character!!! It is easy to find those who want money, power and position. Do they think they are going to gain without losing their souls. Maybe we have forgotten we have souls? Maybe we are so excited about short term gain that we have forgotten that there are consequences!!!!
Those who have dared to stand against evil have been met with "death threats" not only for themselves but their families.
These are truly dangerous times. We have overlooked so much that has already taken place such as the books being banded in public schools. This is one of the actions Hitler took.
Education/reeducation has always been used as a brainwashing technique!
Also the control of information has been going on through various channels of communication especially for those who are willing to believe lies...and there are many! We have forgotten our histories!!!
Citizens are so vulnerable to lies and so easily swayed.
"The frogs in the kettle" are slowly and with unawareness being cooked alive....it is hard to watch!!!!! We are too vulnerable! We are NOT paying attention and we do NOT appreciate our freedoms that have been fought for by "the Fathers of our Country"....all races of "our Fathers" and "Mothers"!!!
Trumps "placeholders" for powerful positions have rightfully NOT been approved ! We as a nation have never been more vulnerable.
Yes I agree with you too and have often thought that Jimmy Carter was one of the best examples of a Christian that I know of. While I don't identify as Christian myself I do know that Christ was the Prince of Peace. And that's exactly how he lived his life, as President Carter and as citizen Carter, constantly working for Peace, Love and Understanding in this world.
May there be more like him and a role model to look up to in these uncertain times.
Thanks Horhai, I identify as a non-theist, but I respect other people's right to believe as they choose so long as they don't try to enforce their beliefs on me. I do think the man, Jesus of Nazareth was a great orator, and a person of parallel to Jimmy Carter, in other words a truly good human being. I do wish we had more Jesus and Jimmy Carter's than trump's, putin's, musk's, and similar creeps. But as long as people worship wealth over kindness - it ain't gonna happen.
I admit to being rather suspicious about the election, but unlike MAGA, I won't rant. I keep hearing Trump tell Johnson they "have a little secret" and wonder what that was. Trump never said what it was, but he also can't keep his mouth shut.
Biden can carry forward Carter’s work on the ERA and direct the archivist to publish it, since it is fully ratified as of 2020. Let the litigation continue after it’s published! I’d love to see the “originalists” contort themselves to deny its validity when it has met the requirements plainly stated in the Constitution.
🤞I am hoping & holding my breath as the days whittle away that this will come to pass….not sure what the possibility is or is not as, as far as I can tell, there is NO indication as to where the chips may fall on this.
Thank you for writing perhaps the most historically important essay of yours I’ve ever read. I say that because it describes a north star that guided Jimmy Carter‘s life although someone would say he was guided by Jesus Christ. I prefer north star because it’s a term sometimes associated with sailors And he was in the Navy. The north star of his values and of how he acted on those values to make the world a better place, including attempting to do so while president (although he was thwarted by political forces he could not control) should in a perfect world guide every politician in America… or at least every member of the Democratic Party. And so, while I marvel at the example of a good life so many spoke of, I am in pain because I know following that example will not happen except in the margins in the years ahead. Unless the Democratic Party breaks with the big money interests that Carter himself hated (Citizens United 😡), it will never direct its energies to defeating the evil that exists in society today (Putin, Trump, Musk Alito, et al) by offering the American people the transformational, sustainable development based future that’s out the waiting to be born…. which Carter knew existed.
I was heartened by the emphasis that was placed on the 39th President's achievements while in office. Too often we've heard about how great he was after his term was over.
If Jimmy Carter taught us anything, it was that we should not dwell on the negativity of our circumstances but, instead, going forward, to keep our eye on the goals we want to achieve for our country.
The Southern Democrats were still transitioning from being racist, misogynistic and xenophobic to being Republicans. Today, the Democrats would have embraced him like they did with Obama.
I've been thinking lately that if Kamala Harris had won the presidential election,,President Carter would have lived at least four more years with a picture of a smiling Rosalyn close by.
I have sadness that he didn’t live to see Harris/Walz win as he had voted for….I think it might have given him a sparkle of content & hope to take with him into whatever comes after. Then, not so nice, another thought occurred to me that he might hang out for awhile in the White House and monitor and whisper in TFFFG’s ear…helping him (as would be his way) or making him cray-cray (as my nasty woman vibe instructs)!
Barbara, about an hour ago I posted a comment here saying that if Kamala had won the election, Carter would have lived another four years with a picture of Rosalyn smiling close by.
Thank you Heather for such a great synopsis of the service today which honored the life of former president Jimmy Carter. As I listened to both Mondale's son and Ford's son share the eulogies their fathers had written YEARS AGO--I couldn't help but realize it was a complete and accurate indictment on Trump (and his supporters) as though it was written today!
Each time I read an article or watch a story of Carter I learn more and more how truly forward thinking and visionary he was. I had not realized his quest to elevate women to positions of power and authority--VERY Jesus like actually :) His early awareness of the effects of climate change, etc...he was truly a MUCH better man than what he was recognized for by our press and fellow politicians. Glad to have been educated!
As I watched Jimmy Carter’s service in Washington, I was profoundly moved. One doesn’t necessarily shed grieving tears for a rare and special man who filled his century on earth with extraordinary accomplishments…none greater than simply and so naturally modeling how to well live one’s life.
My tears tonight were mixed; most were those welling from heartfelt gratitude for - and celebration of - his countless and lifelong examples of pure, native decency and grace.
My other tears were the ones of actual mourning…grief for the current deviation in the moral compass of so many in this country. Through an imperfect storm of fear, ignorance and malignancy, 75 millionAmericans elected to empower hate with safe harbor, as was pointedly referenced from the national cathedral’s pulpit today.
But I believe – and I am bedrock certain that Jimmy Carter would have us all understand, and believe in our hearts – that there is absolutely more goodness than bad in this world. He led a life that demonstrated how each and every one of us must - repeat “must”- pitch in, lend a hand (with or without a hammer in it), BE the Light and share that Light.
“Power and title,” as also referenced today, are not at all the answer. “Do unto others…” is.
I’ll vote for that as long as I can. Thank you Jimmy and Rosalyn.
Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood's simple, yet simply gorgeous, rendition of Imagine was oh so appropriate. I cried hearing it. I've long said that John Lennon's beautiful ode to the planet, and to humanity, should be our national anthem. Jimmy Carter lived that song his entire long life.
His choice of music was just perfect, particularly the entrance piece, The Road Home by Stephen Paulus, and makes me cry every time I hear it. He was welcomed home by Rosalyn and is at peace. He gave us so much and yesterday reminded us of just what that was. Now it is ours to continue in his honor.
I feel certain that God said to Jimmy Carter, “Well done, good and faithful servant. Welcome home.” What a powerful example Jimmy Carter was of living one’s faith.
Yes, Kathleen, I thought it was perfect, simply perfect, for the procession of Carter's casket. Stephen died too soon.
Yes he did. That song tugs at my heart and I offer it whenever a loved one leaves us. It is so poignant. I also had the good fortune to have a son who sang in a men's chorus in college, and while they never sang this particular piece, they did many very similar works. Just beautiful balm for the soul at times like these.
One of the great songs of all time was John Lennon's, ode to the Planet.
Harvey, "Imagine" was our class song in 1973. I recall not voting for it (I was clearly a stupid graduate) and can't remember what I did vote for, but Lennon's beautiful anthem of peace and brotherhood was indeed the best choice for then as well as today and tomorrow.
Margaret MacKenzie -- "Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood's simple, yet simply gorgeous, rendition of Imagine was oh so appropriate."
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aBhchwPGzZE
It must have been torture to tfg keeping his mouth shut at Carter’s funeral. He embodies everything opposite to the man Carter was.
https://theonion.com/jealous-trump-throws-own-state-funeral-to-upstage-carters/
Donny was fighting every instink to try to be the center of attention…watching him fidgeting when they were standing to leave was actually funny! Such a little boy!
Thanks for the link.
Thank you, Ron, for the link. I loved hearing it yesterday and it still brings tears today. Has always been my favorite song, too. Garth and Yearwood's rendition is simply lovely.
I had a medical appointment and so I missed watching this. Thanks for the link. How beautiful in it's simplicity.
I missed it too. I am going to dig around and see if I can find a link.
Ron posted it a couple comments above. Knowing that you are a musician, I'm sure you'll appreciate it. Here it is so you don't need to search.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aBhchwPGzZE
Thanks for posting that link to Imagine.
Thank you , Ron🫶
Thank you for the link.
How does one resolve the apparent conflict between a tribute to a person of faith with a song promoting “no heaven and no religion” ideas? By recognizing that real religion involves making heaven on Earth by repeatedly strengthening the bonds that keep us from thinking it’s “us” against “them” (“re” = redo and “ligion” = ligament = binding), while also recognizing that the phrase “no phony religion” in a beautiful song would sound discordant.
My take away from Carter requesting John Lennon's song Imagine, is that while Carter was a Christian of deep faith...he saw that it's not the only way. There are a number of faith traditions across the planet and that if we are to get to the goal of peace, we have to respect each other...and love each other, no matter the details of our faith. I believe the line that matters the most is that "we live as one".
Well said, Mike.
Perfectly put, Mike.
James, faith does not require adherence to a religious doctrine. It may be nice if the two converge, but for many, they do not. In the case of Christians, faith in Jesus Christ can stand alone, without the discordance organized religion brings.
I agree, but a religious practice is the application of a religious tradition’s founding principles. Without those principles, you don’t have a faith or a religion. With those principles, you do have a faith that is independent of context, and then you need to understand how to apply the principles in specific contexts, which is when a religious practice inevitably emerges.
You are correct in saying that faith in Jesus Christ can stand alone without the discordance organized religions bring, but there’s only one reason why organized religions bring discordance, and that reason is when a religious institution starts disregarding their tradition’s founding principles.
For the record, the two Christian principles are stated by Jesus several times throughout the four Gospels including in Matthew 22:34-40. Everything else is a context-specific application of, or a context-specific disregard for, those two context-independent principles.
Thank you James. So deep , so true, so sought by too few.
One humorous take was Andy Borowitz’s piece yesterday, “Jimmy Carter Says Best Part of Heaven is He Will Never See Trump”
Yes! Grace in the line of fire! It always reminds me of harm ‘Religion’ creates when we replace truth with power over others, particularly females! Preaching, screeching hate is not supposed to be the found of the God of love! Stop them before they get a handmaid on the Supreme Court!
“…more goodness than bad…” I hope so!
Your eloquence with words matches your artistry with photography. Thank you, Peter.
President Carter's accomplishments post Presidency exemplify what an amazing man he was. For someone that has not been President for 45 years, it is amazing to see the genuine love and respect from so many people who were touched by perhaps the greatest humanitarian ever.
And Rosalyn, redefined the role of First Lady participating during his Presidency and long after, like no other First Lady except perhaps Eleanor Roosevelt.
The music documentary of Duane Allman reminds us of Carter's love of music and how much musicians thought of him. The Allman brothers were in their early 20's and were all-in on Jimmy Carter.
My thoughts exactly.
Well said Ally.
Jimmy Carter was a person of true faith. He understood that you don’t just hope for the best or prepare for the worst. You do what you can to make the world a better place, and his life proved that he was right. Now he’s left that legacy for us to follow.
James, that's so true. And his long and productive life disproves the notion that "the good die young" -- thankfully, James Earl Carter didn't.
Personally, I think it's true that the good die young based on my definition of old. To me, when a person thinks they know everything, and they're always right, they're old regardless of their chronological age. By that definition, Jimmy Carter died young. As for me, I hope I die before I get old.
James, nicely put. I am actually old in years, but I hope that I can keep realizing how much I do not know and continue learning as i do from so many who post here. I thought the eulogies were on point as a tribute to Carter and also a pointed reference in some cases to death star.
Some of the news accounts I read mentioned "staring obviously at tcf" as they talked about Carter's attributes.
Well-thought and said, James. And may we all.
Trae Crowder, a comedian who calls himself the “liberal redneck” (and is worth following), said “Jimmy Carter, who died at the age of 100, or, as the Democrats would say, in the prime of his life …” Touché, especially with 91-year-old Chuck Grassley third in line to the throne… oops, I meant the presidency (sorry Chief Roberts).
Peter, your eloquently expressed feelings and values are clearly the foundation for your photographs that we dearly treasure.
Saw a bill board with his pic online with the inscription: ChARacTER
Guess who most distinctly lacked it? I hope it made the Orange Menace squirm, and I don’t blame Karen Pence or GWB for snubbing Trump.
I wouldn't have thought Karen Pence had it in her -- good for her. And good for Bush.
Looks like Michelle Obama could not bear to sit next to him and did not attend. Hers is a conspicuous absence.
“Scheduling conflict”
I tend to believe the scheduling conflict, as she always says to go high. And I do think she would have given him a look that would have shriveled the mushroom.
Also, tfg’s expression never changed from his usual scowl.
I say bravo for her --
If the OM squirmed, that would suggest (1) that he understood what he was hearing, and (2) that he has enough self-awareness to realize the contrast. I doubt it. OTOH, it might have meant that his girdle was too tight. That I could believe.
More than a snub coming in Judge Merchan's Courtroom this Friday 1/10/25 morning in less than one hour from now.
Felon 34X sentencing set for 9:30AM Eastern & 6:30 AM Pacific.
****************
Sentence Hearing Completed:
Felon 34X did speak on the record as is ALL felons right with his standard Campaign riffs.
Judge Merchan spoke at 10:02 am. Audio of the hearing will be broadcast soon after the hearing ends. Available before 11:00 AM Eastern.
Paraphrasing Merchan "Unconditional Discharge" period.
The Judge OFF the Bench abruptly at 10:08 am Eastern.
FINAL: The President Elect is a formally convicted felon 34X.
Bryan, is it too early for popcorn?
Convicted and soon to be in the history books.
Place cornels in popcorn machine and pop but don’t eat yet.
Now eat the popcorn.its final. Convicted forevermore in the history books.
Counselor, if there is a link to that, can you post it? My search skills suck, and my scatterbrain goes down too many rabbit holes when looking.
When GWB was in office, I thought he was an absolute idiot. I'm still not very fond of him, but a year or so ago, I read something that redeemed him somewhat. I've recommended this book on this forum often" "Shall We Wake the President: Two Centuries of Disaster Management from the Oval Office" by Tevi Troy.
Apparently, while in office, Bush read about the 1918 Flu and was so concerned that he took some action! I am very concerned that should another pandemic happen under Trump Part Two that this world would not get off as "easy" as it did with COVID. I think a great percentage of the populace absolutely will not wear masks, take a vaccine, etc.
Wow!!! Brilliant!!!
Unfortunately, in today's America, there is more bad than good, as evidenced by a plurality of citizens who voted for Trump to return to the White House to continue his evil and chaotic ways. We, collectively, cannot say "That's not who we are." Elections have consequences.
It was not a plurality.
He won by a slim 1.48% margin
1.7% did not vote for either candidate
15 million did not vote.
Most Americans did not vote for trump.
There are the slimmest of margins in the Congress.
He has no mandate.
There is more good than bad in America. Don't let the evil loudmouths make you think otherwise.
Yes, there is no Trump mandate.Also people did not sign off of what he is pushing.No one voted for annexing Canadá and invading Greenland not even the rubes who voted for him.There was no mention in the Republican platform of taking over the Panama Canal and renaming it.This is the stuff of a madman and I and others won’t buy any of it. Smh
It's a distraction from the who knew bringing down prices was so hard guy.
Mandate or not, he has all the power come 1/20 and he's going to use it as best he can to benefit himself and his rich buddies.
Hey maga, how does putting rich people in charge drain the swamp?
It's a distraction while he robs the country and supports billionaires and dictators in lining their already full to bursting pockets. His only goals are staying out of jail and stealing as much of the country's wealth as he can.
Distraction, smokescreen, gaslighting, call it what you will. He throws this stuff out to rile up others while he continues on his plunder. But we cannot take anything this madman says as pure jest. He is like a loose cannon and it is hard to tell where he is going with a lot of this bs, be it a"distraction" or no. Germans did not take Hitler seriously until it was too late.
I had the pleasure of listening to Simon Rosenberg and Hopium yesterday. He pointedly says not to just brush off his rantings as distractions, Trump just being Trump. The president of the US is a powerful position and his proclamations have ramifications, no matter how harebrained they may seem. We need to hold him and his administration accountable for the things they say, and so does our media, as weak-kneed as it is these days.
Yes, the media is weak-kneed but Meidas is fighting the good fight against MAGA disinfo!
“Anyway, I posted the Trump screenshot, and in ALL CAPS (because we know that’s how MAGA prefers to communicate), I wrote:
WAKE UP! ALL OF THIS IS TO DISTRACT YOU! PRICES ARE NOT GETTING LOWER. HOUSING IS NOT BEING SOLVED. THERE IS NO UKRAINE PEACE DEAL. HE IS A WEAPON OF MASS DISTRACTION. DO NOT FALL FOR IT AGAIN!!
Here’s the post, which has been viewed over 1.2 million times in 48 hours (mostly by my target audience: MAGA).”
https://www.meidasplus.com/p/maga-attacked-me-for-this-simple?
From what I understand MAGA is not happy. These oligarchs actually want to import immigrants, raise the debt ceiling to accommodate their outlandish increases and immigrants themselves. (all stuff MAGA hates)
Thank you Barbara, you provided about the same answer I would have. …there’s the number of registered voters (approximately a third) who just do not participate in or fulfill one of the few - but most important civic duties - that of educating themselves, if not at least once every two years, once every four years and participating in our wonderful society by VOTING. …and then there is that significant number of those who voted for Biden/Harris in 2020, who did not seem to vote in the 2024 election. What happened to or where were they?
We - Democrats and…along with other wise, sane and smart Americans [yes, most Democrats do seem to be smart, sane and wise] - have to mobilize like minded individuals to fulfill their civic duty in 2026 and the Party needs to use/spend/invest the monies they solicit and receive smartly and wisely [it’s sometimes referred to as being prudent] and help find and motivate some superb democratic candidates to run for local, state and national positions. The handwriting is on the wall, the Democrats must have as one of their top objectives after the 2028 election: increasing the size of the Supreme Court!
I agree most Americans are good people who want peace and prosperity in their lives. The 15 million missing voters haunts me. I can't shake the gut feeling there was some dark fooling around with ballots.
I listened to an interview Tim Miller of The Bulwark did with Derek Thompson yesterday. It was absolutely fascinating. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-bulwark-podcast/id1447684472?i=1000683368866
Jim, I've been pounding this issue for quite some time. More people did not vote than voted for either Harris or TCF (now in capitals, because he will be sentenced today).
See how they did it in Georgia, where one woman "challenged" the registrations of 32,379 voters in: https://www.watchvigilantesinc.com/
Then there is https://www.propublica.org/article/right-wing-activists-georgia-voter-challenges
Better yet an expansion of individuals who's the "Vigilantes Inc" votes were suppressed at "Suppressed & Sabotaged 2024 • BRAVE NEW FILMS (BNF)
on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8t_boQO6Yyc
What you have to do to try to stop the "vigilantes" from sabotaging your right to vote n Georgia. See https://www.splcenter.org/georgia-voter-challenges-know-your-rights
I’m going to attempt to find sometime this weekend to view and/or read your linked items…Thanks.
Yup, silence is complicity.
I can't assume that. The political climate in America is so corrupted and chaotic right now. The propaganda machine has been at work for many years. Too many Americans think up is down. Also. Gerrymandering and voter suppression have taken their toll.
What does disturb me is the deliberate choice people made to vote for someone they know in their heart is evil and a clear and present danger to our Democratic way of life. That hurts.
But their pastor told them to
: ((
Thank you. "Save Our Democracy!" is the rallying cry these days, but "our democracy" was in real trouble before Trump was elected the first time but many people -- primarily white middle-class-and-up straight people, I suspect -- didn't realize it and weren't already fighting (and voting) to make it better.
I've never been in the "If you don't vote, you can't complain" camp. Some people who don't vote have a better understanding of the situation than many of those who do vote. I take the existence of non-voters and even Trump voters as a challenge to those of us to vote in every election, from the most local to the presidential. We need to make the connections clearer between "government" and our daily lives. And we need to hold our elected officials accountable.
(Overruling Citizens United would also help.)
Overruling Citizens United is essential!
"We need to make the connections clearer between "government" and our daily lives." Great point!!
This is a hard sell if the media is complicit in spreading lies about the good the Democrats do for people.
I'm with you on that. They made a decision that has an effect on all of us and I resent that.
Spot on, Barbara. There *is* more good than bad in America, except for our collective memory, which is really bad. But we will soon be reminded.
I general I think people are more "good" than bad, but bad has a practical advantage as it can ride on entropy. It's so much easier to bully than liberate. So much easier to destroy than build something worthwhile. Though ugliness gets old at some point.
J L--I don't think quantifying "bad" vs "good" has any practical purpose. Doesn't matter how many good people there are if they are not engaged in the process. And being engaged takes work. And yes, as you note, hate is easier than love--or even "like."
Or even tolerance.
Love takes work, attention, selflessness . . .
And when the two are competing, "bad" definitely has the advantages of being ignited by hate, sustained by ignorance, and "riding on entropy,"* in its inexorable trajectory of destruction. Tragically, once it "gets old," who will be able to do anything about it?
_____________________________
*Your phrase, "riding on entropy" is so poetic, it ironically evoked dark alternate lyrics for "Walking in Rhythm":
https://youtu.be/5y3CBI260Z8
- Pulled Quote -
“At our best,” Biden said, “we share the better parts of ourselves: joy, solidarity, love, commitment. Not for reward, but in reverence for the incredible gift of life we’ve all been granted. To make every minute of our time here on Earth count.” “That’s the definition of a good life,” Biden said. It was the life Jimmy Carter lived for 100 years: a “good life of purpose and meaning, of character driven by destiny and filled with the power of faith, hope, and love.”
Amen.
Mr Ted Ford's reading of President Ford's eulogy. The apple does not fall far from the tree. https://www.c-span.org/clip/public-affairs-event/user-clip-the-doth-not-fall-far-from-the-tree-14minvid/5148492
Many disagree with my including President Ford as one of the two best Presidents, right along there with President Carter. President Carter and President Ford exchanged pre-written eulogies for their eventual funerals. Those dueling eulogies deepen my conviction that two men of impeccable characters and divergent politics really can like and esteem the best each sees in the other.
Oregon had the same treat with Gordon Smith (R) and Ron Wyden (D) as our Oregon senators in the early 2000's. They walked into the Senate chamber every morning, side by side, shook hands, and went to their respective "sides". Both worked, first and foremost, for Oregon.
So well said, Peter. I grieved for what was lost in our recent election, the character that Carter lived and I believe Biden reflects.
Well said; thank you, Peter.
Beautiful. Thank you.
Thank you for your eloquent and heartfelt remarks. They inspired me to repost my reply to Substack’s Civil Discourse with Joyce Vance:
"Jimmy Carter seems to have timed his death to send the country a much needed message."
He couldn't have timed it better for another reason. It could not have been just me listening to eulogy after eulogy praising President Carter's stellar character and not think of the spectacular contrast to that of the scumbag who will reoccupy the WH.
I will forever treasure meeting President Carter and our correspondence. He told me that he never felt any conflict between his scientific background and his faith. He had the kIndest face I've ever seen. I sent him my first book, not knowing if he would bother reading it. Not only did he read it but he sent me an incredibly thoughtful letter about how much he enjoyed it and went on to encourage my writing. I believe that he was the closest thing to Jesus on this earth. I brought it to his attention that they even shared the same initials....
Peter, I regret I could only give Professor Richardson one ❤️ for today’s letter and I regret I can only give you one ❤️ for this comment. Well said, thank you.
Magnificent, Peter!
thank you -- beautiful
Wonderful comment!!
I loved Carter’s grandson’s story of how he would make pancakes and how he made a cradle with his own hands for any one of his grandchildren. The best, however, came from Joe Biden when he spoke about the dignity and respect Jimmy Carter gave everyone, no matter who they were. When Biden was speaking, he glared right at Donald who was squirming in his seat like a child who is bored. Melania never smiled or made any expression. This is what we get to look forward to.
Thank you Heather.
I was going to comment about the “hand over heart” gesture that everyone else made except the felon-in-chief, but this is about the character of dear President Carter, who truly earned the honorary title forevermore. Rest in peace, sir.
President Carter saved so many lives around the world that should be called the first "President Pro Life"
I watched him as the Flag went past, when it was already gone, he finally put his hand over his Stomach. Must not have learned too much in his previous 4 years in office.
trump was always bad with geography. I guess that applies to anatomy also. maybe he has no heart, and this was the closest to one he could get.
Well said!
Who nudged or poked him? /s
🤣🤣🤣
Susan, that is what I call the "ballpark salute" where caps (on the occasion that they are worn) are removed and placed on the stomach, rather than the correct position, with the hand over the heart.
I saw that too. Reprehensible in his disrespect.
trump was complaining about the flag being lowered. hmmmm. I think he was there only because if he didn't show up, it would look bad.
When the US National Colors are presented in a procession, uniformed personnel should render the military salute (right hand to right eyebrow). All citizens should render the hand salute, which is the right hand held over the heart; if a cover (hat) is worn and not part of a uniform, it should be removed and positioned at or above the left shoulder so the hand remains over the heart. As the presentation passes, the salute is slowly released. Remain standing until directed to sit.
Dignity. A concept worthy of contemplation and guidance. Where does it show? Where does it lack? How is it done?
Yes, and today, Trump has to go before Judge Merchon to receive his sentence for campaign finance violations. I hope, even if it’s a flutter, that he realizes how out of his depth he is at leading this nation.
The judge has already said he will not impose jail time, fines, or probation… so what’s the point?
It affects the Trump organization’s dealings in NY. It also changes his travel status - countries would have to make exceptions to allow a felon to enter their country.
Now trump would have to have world leaders come bow to him at Mar a Lago. A sign of power like his handshakees.
Or they can blow him off and stay in their home countries.
Read the Frozen River. Takes place in the late 1700s. A rich and powerful judge commits rapes and was told to spend time at home (don't leave the country type of thing), but he flees the county, but does show up for court. Of course, he was found innocent by a jury of all men He then resumes his judge position. Does this sound familiar?
There is no punishment, yet there is a conviction. It is important, as many felons are not permitted to vote...
So not surprised!
Yet, all I saw yesterday was how Michelle Obama missed the service and how Mrs. Pence ignored trump ( I didn't know about the Bush snub) and Kamala looked at trump. Of yes, one person must have not read or just watched the clip of Kamala looking at trump and made the comment that Biden wasn't there! It goes to show you how a cherry picked snippet influences gullible people.
It has renewed my respect for good "Carpenters"
I've been occupied by watching the evolving consequences of the urban wildfires in an area we left because of ever increasing heat wave extremes in both maximum heat and duration of long dry spells, combined with periods of heavier rainfall in shorter periods that cause floods that exceed the mitigation efforts designed for older climate conditions.
Apparently, as of yesterday, 16 families that our family's friends in Pasadena know, may have lost their homes in Altadena. I do know at least the auditorium of the Eliot Middle School was on fire in a little pocket in the larger area of the southern edge of a much larger area. I had attended a lot of Pasadena IBM User Group (PIBMUG) meeting there during the dozen years I worked in Pasadena. PIBMUG earlier meetings had started at Caltech with some interesting guest speakers. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p7KQibWUDcM
I don't remember exactly where Steve Bass live(d/s) but I believe it was in the Eaton fire burned (or evacuation area if he lived in Pasadena. Part of Steve's author's bio on Amazon:
"...I first learned about computers in 1982 with an IBM PC I bought from Computerland. When I asked them for support, they said, "Don't use it in the shower."
The following day, I founded the Pasadena IBM Users Group. After 24 years, I finally closed the organization, releasing the over 2,400 former members onto the streets (http://www.pibmug.com). Be careful out there. And in the late 1980s, I co-founded the Association of Personal Computer User Groups (http://www.apcug.org), a nationwide organization serving user groups..."
Then there is one of my favorite Data Scientists who(while working with Caltech, I assume) left a future Nobel Prize winning team (for their LIGO work and I'd seen when later visiting the Hanford LIGO site), to take up the climate data challenges at JPL. I don't know if he still lives about 3 miles from JPL but I ran across the following article that describes how he and his family felt during the Bobcat Fire that threatened the area for months in 2020.
See https://www.propublica.org/article/the-climate-crisis-is-worse-than-you-can-imagine-heres-what-happens-if-you-try
I'm no where near as smart or dedicated as Peter, but I have a strong dose of concern for what he sees as some of the best data and analysis of the trouble we are facing if we don't redouble or triple our efforts to limit climate heating. Last I knew he was living within 3 miles of JPL and at least in the evacuation zone.
Big Oil may deny what they really know about climate change costs, but I have to believe the Insurance Companies losses will make insurance impossible to provide at affordable prices. How can anyone imagine trying to replace all that is being lost already, much less how much more will be lost if no changes are made?
It was a beautiful service, befitting the man Carter was, decent, honest, respectful, and generous.
I noted that when Biden uttered the words "abuse of power", he pointedly looked towards Trump. Message sent, but I doubt it was received.
Seems to me that abuse of power is humanity's most tragic and dangerous, perhaps fatal flaw. We have met the enemy and he is us. Can we learn from past mistakes before it's too late?
God I hope we are given Guidance to step away from misleading misanthropes who are multiplying around the doors into the Oval Office. I am also working now, because of the humane gifts from Jimmy Carter’s funeral service today, to turn my prayers to light and connection with my neighbors and coworkers in every encounter hence forward.
Fear is not a comfortable feeling. Whatever is coming will be met best with every effort to connect, exchange plans to deal with our challenges and create safety for all.
I’m so pleased I had the opportunity to ‘attend’ the whole funeral service on the internet today.
We might have been far better off keeping Carter, but I was a junior in high school and had concerns about Reagan. Carter was almost universally reviled then, but he told us what we needed to hear. Reagan told many people what they wanted to hear while laying the groundwork for our current mess.
Thank you Carol O,
I was busy doing family things and didn't even turn the television on or search for it on the Internet, but I'm going to make time to watch President Carter's entire funeral. Somehow I know I'm going to be inspired by it. Something you said clicked, and I asked myself, how can I make America a better place other than voting? And it occurred to me that in order to help my community I need to connect more with my neighbors. To be honest I've always left the vast majority of that to my wife. It's time for me to get more involved. I may be old, but I can still learn a few more tricks.
Thanks again for the inspiration 👍
Same here, Justin. I have a free day today (except for taking the cat to the vet. Stupid Orange Boy, yet again...) and would like to watch it in its entirety.
Reading Heather's words, I couldn't help thinking, 'Are you listening to this Trump? Are you listening to this GOP?'
I don’t, unfortunately. The Orange Menace was inattentive as he wasn’t the center of attention.
Inattentive is a kind way to describe him. Whenever the camera panned around to the row of presidents. he looked either asleep or unconscious. Or daydreaming, about goodness knows what. But thoroughly unengaged. The antithesis to President Carter and the gravity of the Oval Office.
Not unlike his inattentiveness at his trial.
Not us, him and his cult, and the repubs in general.
Can we? Most certainly. Have we? No
Definitely was not received, no capacity for that.
Djt's face was a 'mask' throughout the service...or so it seemed
He was chewing his teeth and contorting his mouth like a coke head.
His eyes were closed half the time like a bored little kid.
Sandra, much of the time he looked asleep....or fighting sleep!!!!
When President Carter worked on building houses with Habitat, he got his hands dirty. When he worked the peanut fields, he got his hands dirty. When he went to impoverished countries to help monitor elections and spread health initiatives, he got his hands dirty. As dirty as his hands got, his ideals were about as clean and pure as any person. Juxtaposing Carter’s funeral with Trump’s inauguration obviates how low our standards have become.
Phil, I have posted this here a few times, but never know who sees it, so will post again….one of my favorite poems “To Be of Use” by Marge Piercy, to me it describes those who just do the right thing….because it’s the right thing to do: https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/57673/to-be-of-use Jimmy Carter was the first president I was eligible (21 was the age limit then) to vote for…and did so twice & very sad he didn’t win reelection—I mean you could tell he was an agent of positive change! Highest praise: He was a good man. Although I am not at all a deist or religious, I will say Amen to that!
Hello Barbara... Thanks for illustrating how Jimmy Carter put his Post-Presidency to use furthering Humankind... Contrast this Service with how DJT has put his Post-Nov 5 2020 time to use, and where DJT has spent it...
Yeah, Apache, building up versus tearing down….they could not be more opposite in character/actions. I hope his example and his & Rosalynn’s actions serve as an example to all, especially to our youth who are/will be stepping up to lead
Hello Barbara... Maybe the Seeds of a Campaign once DJT is no longer President... Hmm?
Jimmy and Rosalyn Carter were such an amazing team. Is there another couple that accomplished so much in their lifetimes in the service of mankind.
Their example is humbling as well as inspirational.
It seems to me rather unprecedented that the Republicans would follow the dictates of an ex-president and now his megalomaniac backroads on how and what to vote for, yet this is where we are.
Jimmy Carter was the antithesis of a Southerner MAGA. He loved everyone. They hate everyone. He was progressive. They are regressive.
Change is hard and change is usually good, but Project 2025 is not good change. Project 2025 is not conservative, it is regressive and who we were in the past is not worth returning to.
Thanks, Barbara, for re-posting this poem. To me, it's the very definition of Jimmy Carter.
Barbara, the year was 1972 when 18-year-olds were allowed to vote: I know this because I was 18 that year and was able to vote for Joe Biden as Delaware’s Democrat Senator. I’m a born and raised Delawarean and stood about 10 feet in front of him and his late wife Neilia at a Democratic rally at Christiana High School (Newark, DE) days before the 1972 election. He was our first Democrat Senator in my then young life and we were hopeful that things would change that year, but unfortunately, many changes were not for the better in so many ways (Mrs. Biden and their daughter would die the next month and Nixon won another term). It’s a memory that will always be happy and sad for me. I volunteer for the League of Women Voters and we go to high schools and register 17-1/2 and 18-year-olds to vote and I tell young people that I was the first generation of 18-year-olds who would eligible to vote—they don’t know that the voting age was changed from 21 because it’s been this way for over 50 years—we take it for granted. I also tell them that the 18-year-olds did not make a difference in 1972 national election because they didn’t vote in significant numbers (low turnout) and I encourage young people that they are our future and can make a difference. Perhaps they will understand in 2028?
Also, Jimmy Carter has been the only President that I’ve ever been able to shake hands with—he jumped the lines that separated us from him (as he was known to do!) and made his way to greet the crowd waiting to get a chance to see him exit from attending an speaking event in Columbia, MO when he was then President! The Secret Service guys moved at the speed of light to get to him! Bless him and his family and loved ones ☮️💟
Linda, I, too, voted for the first time in a midterm election (1975 for me) and it is hard to reconcile the breezy dismissal of the importance of voting that happens nowadays with the struggles we had to get the voting age lowered to 18. Carter was the first presidential candidate I was able to vote for. I very much wish he had been a better campaigner who could have tanked Reagan's steamroller but his commitment to integrity, truth, and reality ran counter to the fantasies of most Americans--long before the current Disinformation Media Flood--and was a scary sign of things to come.
My first Presidential vote as well!
Thank you for sharing “To Be of Use.” Marge Piercy is quite an interesting person. MargePiercy.com
I had never seen this poem before. I loved it. Thank you
Thank you for posting the poem. It makes one think about what is truly important in life. We need more helpers and fewer destroyers. Trump, I'm looking at you.
Barbara, thanks for the poetry link. What a lovely thought to start the day. Enjoyed listening to the funeral on the way to an appointment and happy to hear it continuing when the appointment finished. It was a heartfelt and fitting tribute to a wonderful man. The world needs more like him.
Beautiful share Barb; I love that.
Thank you for that link! Beautiful.
Since I am late on the forum, you might not see the link I am posting today. Our beloved HCR in a 42 minute interview, two days ago on the Meidas Network youtube channel "Politics Girl". So worth the time!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QXpORF73n_8
That was a great listen!
With no slight to meant to you, I felt that not having a full orchestra behind them made it all the better for this moment.
Barbara Keating,
...and you are one to give of yourself by sharing this powerful poem with us (even I, an "old folk" am encouraged)....there are ways even I can give....
This is my first reading of this poem and it is beautiful, as it is also inspiring. I love it. Thank you. You shared at the right time for the right occasion.
Barbara, Carter was the first president I voted for as well. I turned 18 in 1976, and was able to vote in Oregon's primary that May. It was ratified in 1971, and I believe that 1972 was the first presidential election that was impacted by it.
I note with pride that the case was Mitchell v. Oregon.
That is an amazing poem, one I first read in the 9th grade.
Agreed. I think it was part of one of the most fundamental of Christian values that Carter practiced, which is humility. You might be the son of God, you still wash your disciples' feet.
Yet for all the hard work done with those hands, they remained clean.
When his grandson told the story of his grandfather calling him I laughed through my tears. I’m not calling you. I’m taking a picture. Thank you President Carter for your selfless service to our county.
If I had to rate them, I would say Jason Carter's eulogy was the best. He honored our tears and provided us a reason to laugh/smile for our 39th President.
I neglected to mention the eulogy of President Ford’s son - Steve Ford.
Yes!!
Yes. And Ted Mondale's eulogy was wonderful as well.
Agree, Gloria. Actually, all of them were wonderful, now that I think about it!
They were all excellent, with Jason Carter's and President Biden's perhaps the most memorable for me, but Andrew Young's homily was deeply moving, when he said Jimmy Carter "had a tough mind and a tender heart" and "symbolized the greatness of America." I feel that Carter's memorial service from beginning to end was like a long and beautiful meditation on heart and spirit.
Good morning, Lynell! Sad that I missed this.
I found it grotesque to see Trump there on the eve of his sentencing, eyes closed like a dozing reptile, surrounded by former presidents and vice presidents, all of whom at least understood the immense responsibility of the job and their oath to uphold the constitution. And Hillary and Kamala, the women he verbally assaulted to defeat them, having to sit just a few feet away, as if none of it had ever happened.
He is the antithesis everything Jimmy Carter was, in all things.
I felt I was watching the funeral of democracy.
I felt the exact opposite. He sat there squiring, uncomfortable and afraid to be in the company of goodness. He was shunted to the side in the second row and had to listen to good people talk of character. I saw a symbol in the videos. He was outnumbered by the good people. Our ancestors Washington, Hamilton, MLK, JFK, Mondale, Rosa Parks, and all our historical and memorable voices of freedom and patriotism showed up in the Cathedral yesterday. They reminded us we will be ok. We need to fight like they did.
Thank you, Barbara. I love your perspective.
I like what you said, but he was not “shunted to the side.” There is a deliberate formality to the seating.
Thank you for the clarification. Still. The visuals were good with him off to the side.
And there he was, sitting at the end of the row, stewing in his hatred while his wife stewed in hers. Each word spoken came from a mouth he cannot wait to spike onto his nailhead of loathing. That box, that casket casting its cold breath of mortality across the orange leather of his skin, infuriating under that honored flag that should fly at full mast every day since his glorious exaltation back to the presidency. There will be no half-mast come January 21. No hands to the heart, no pledge to decency or character. Just his half-closed eyes envisioning them all cast into the Hell he cannot wait to unleash upon the earth.
I think it might be more appropriate to refer to Melania as Donald's escort. I'm pretty sure she stopped being his wife some 18 years ago. These days, her public appearances with Donald are limited to those specified and compensated according to a contractual agreement. When "off the clock," she's a cougar on the prowl.
I found Andrew Young’s remarks particularly poignant, but it was President Carter’s grandson Jason Carter who brought it home for me. These two men, who knew Jimmy Carter so well, defined him as a man whose moral compass was always true: I couldn't agree more.
It was difficult watching the service – catching occasional glimpses of DJT who is the living antithesis of everything Jimmy Carter represented.
For DJT to be so upset over the flags being at half mast and staff during his inauguration shows just how petty Trump really is.
And whose constant scowl was disgusting. He just can’t handle it when it’s not all about him.
When isn’t he scowling? When isn’t he lying? Trump is telling the truth about how he wants to be a dictator, and about the nasty things he plans to do. I think he won’t leave office.
Kathy Hughes,
I "liked" your comment .......................I also believe that anyone who thinks
Trump will leave the Presidency in 4 years is out of their minds. Reality has been slapping us in the face more and more since he left his first catastrophic term!!! We have been made aware of his convictions and yet we ignore the reality of losing freedoms we have gained due to the spilt blood of American patriots. Trump calls these patriots, "losers".
Our laws are not holding back a tyrant and not even "in and of himself" a capable tyrant. I say once again, he is a willing puppet being placed in a position of power by his puppeteers. He is just basking in power. He loves the attention! The hungry wolves lusting after money and power are close on his heels! He is THEIR pathway to power!!!
Thank you President Biden for your decency and leadership and faith!
I only wish we had given Netanyahu NOTHING until the hostages were brought home. By making the choice to send weapons, we gave him power to rip apart the lives of innocent and helpless people in the Middle East including citizens in Israel and to build up more poverty....take away education opportunities for thousands of children, and to increase hatred against America.
Thank you Jimmy Carter!!! May you rest in peace. We need more like you.
Agreed - the contrast could not have been more striking. The “love and respect” with which Jimmy Carter met the world and lived his life are not in Trump’s vocabulary or world view.
Elegant, insightful. Thanks for this. But a thought hovered over it all ... one more helicopter and we never get Reagan. What would our world look like with another four years with Carter?
What would our word look like with 4 years (or more) of Al Gore, instead of Bush Jr? Just think of the progress that would have been made toward addressing climate change.
What would our world look like with 4 years (or more) of Hillary Clinton, instead of Trump? Just think if Putin would not have been emboldened to invade Ukraine, and how the US would have addressed the pandemic from a position of medical knowledge, and how white supremacists would not have been emboldened as they were under Trump, etc, etc.
And now ...
"While Obama, sitting next to Trump, spoke to him, former president Bush refused to acknowledge Trump, instead walking past him and giving a familiar greeting to Obama."... Even though none of the Bushes gave endorsements in the last Election. at least GWB seems to acknowledge how bad DJT is... I also saw a clip of DJT glaring at Karmala... I hope that DJT doesn't make her Public Enemy #1... Finally some Good News out of the Supreme Court Today... DJT's Appeal to delay his NYC Sentencing was DENIED.... Maybe the Walls-Are-Starting-To-Close-In on DJT.... In Addiction, part of Jack Smith's Mar-a-Lago Stolen Classified Documents Report will be released... More Good News...
Former President Obama is much more dignified than the Orange Menace, but the Orange Menace threw shade on the former president every chance hegot. Ta-Nehisi Coates, who is one the best writers of our time, notes we got Trump precisely because of electing Obama.
I have thought for a long time that this is the backlash for electing a black president. And one as articulate and compassionate, accomplished and unflappable as Obama is, makes some people in this country all the more angry. I just don't get how they can hold on to all that animosity, and then vote to throw everything away based on it.
The tea party agrees with Coates
I always felt then - and certainly now, as probably Biden regrettably feels - that it should have been, if not a Biden/Hillary ticket, Biden along with someone, that was offered up to the American voters in the 2016 presidential election!
Yes, he will have the title of felon, but without any consequences. He will still rule with a heavy hand, spew lies and hate, and do as he pleases. One thing he will never have is the title of A Good Man.
We should be concerned about Trump's manipulation of SCOTUS. Look at the many terrible decisions they have handed down since Trump left office.
And they have used Trump (and Cohn's) delay tactic to delay decisions involving Trump. What other citizen could petition SCOTUS to have them intervene in a personal Federal case? Trump and his billionaire buddies are truly above the law.
Poverty is the opposite of Justice.
Playing out, “When they go low, we go high”…
I thought he was trying to bully her. It felt like it did on the stage with H. Clinton at the debate. VP Harris and her husband looked in all kinds of pain (so sad to see.) I was also concerned for the Bidens. They looked grim and frail.
I was pleased at the Bush maneuver but surprised at Obama. Can you explain what Obama was up to being so friendly?
I believe he is following what MIchelle always preaches, to "go high".
I have mixed feelings about that belief. In my heart, I want to follow it, but my brain says that ancient customs of shunning should come back.
It has been said that Trump’s motivation to run for President was inspired by Obama’s comments about him during the 2015 Correspondents dinner/roast…Call it up on YouTube and watch Trump really squirm…
One can never really know where the path not taken would led, but before Reagan, Carter and even Nixon favored environmental protection. I wonder where we would be had unbroken efforts continued.
Good point J L. Reagan, the Bushes and Trump have all supported the fossil fuel industries to the detriment of the environment and our health.
Don’t put a Bush in with the good guys…
USA Incorporated.
And if RFK and MLK? It’s been going on for a sad long time.
Cathy, your wish list is absolutely right.
Thanks for the etc, etc instead of mentioning all the things that are going to get bad and worse under the felon president.
Yeah, Arthur, the big “what if”! I voted for him (2nd time) to be re-elected and was sorely disappointed when he didn’t win…such a lost opportunity. Same, too, as others here have commented on Gore’s (questionable) loss. Dunno, perhaps somewhere in this massive Universe there is an alternative reality playing out…would be interesting to see IF such a path made any consequential differences. Guess we’ll never know!
Much of history turns on what, in retrospect, are flukes. The ones that we find compelling are those that had significant implications. There were, are, will be -- must be -- innumerable others that weren't significant because, well ... because they weren't. I'm not trying to be obtuse here ... just probabilistic. Consider where we'd be today if the bullet that pierced Trump's ear was two inches to the left.....
Yes, the “butterfly effect”….and all the “what if’s?”, which honestly could be applied to many aspects of our lives…not just the “grand stage” ones.
or the bullets targeting Lincoln and Kennedy missed.....
Or, more recently, what if winter storm Blair, with its 9 inches of city-stopping snow in DC on 1/6/25, had happened 4 years ago?
Pax ,I wish that would be repeated on January 20th. Just in case, I'm thinking of a snow storm and frigid temperatures 😄
I believe there is an infinite number of alternate realities; it’s just this one where our consciousness resides. And it’s really, really hard to be positive when things are so badly mangled.
I love that.
An amazing example of the contingent nature of history.
Beautifully told How strange that we are going from the passing of Carter such a honorable man and president so close to the day that his exact opposite is supposed to be “sworn “ in A good man who loved his neighbor to the exact opposite Someone who told the truth and followed the constitution to…. Someone who did good to…. So unbelievable and tragic for this country
Hope we endure Susan ,and at the end of a tunnel, we can MADA (Make America Decent Again).
Let's focus on that (MADA) for the next four years, Ricardo. I'm in!
👍
I'm there!
Oh please no! No more MA.. anything. Let just go back to being called Americans please.
I was not thinking of blue, white and red hats with golden letters and not even a slogan, my intention was to point to a goal at the end of the tunnel. After your reply I understand some people would adopt it as slogan. Point well taken Barbara.
Well if I did then I guess others would.
Barbara, I so agree!
Yes, indeed. The contradictions are profound.
Oh, the contrast between Carter’s well-lived life and Trump’s parasitic mimic of a human.
Thank you, Dr. Richardson. I have always admired President Carter as a human being and as the only living Christian I've ever heard of. While I don't share his belief, I deeply respect and admire him.
Like our current President, Joe Biden, Jimmy Carter accomplished far more in his four years of the Presidency than he was ever given credit for. It wasn't until he died that I learned all his wonderful accomplishments. I had the pleasure of working on helping to build a couple of homes in his Habitat for Humanity - what a marvelous gift that was both for the givers and the receivers. I'm proud that I voted for Jimmy Carter in 1976 and 1980.
As a young Argentinian living Buenos Aires at that time in the middle of a bloody military dictatorship ,President Carter and his active defense of human rights was the only hope we had and actually save hundreds of young people's lives. Thanks MrPresident .Eternity .
Thank you, Ricardo, for this additional testimony to President Carter's love of all mankind.
Fay, we might need another Jimmy Carter, this time, for the American people. Thanks for your comment and reply 👍
Ricardo Grinbank,
Where will we find that person? Where will we find such bravery...such goodness...such character!!! It is easy to find those who want money, power and position. Do they think they are going to gain without losing their souls. Maybe we have forgotten we have souls? Maybe we are so excited about short term gain that we have forgotten that there are consequences!!!!
Those who have dared to stand against evil have been met with "death threats" not only for themselves but their families.
These are truly dangerous times. We have overlooked so much that has already taken place such as the books being banded in public schools. This is one of the actions Hitler took.
Education/reeducation has always been used as a brainwashing technique!
Also the control of information has been going on through various channels of communication especially for those who are willing to believe lies...and there are many! We have forgotten our histories!!!
Citizens are so vulnerable to lies and so easily swayed.
"The frogs in the kettle" are slowly and with unawareness being cooked alive....it is hard to watch!!!!! We are too vulnerable! We are NOT paying attention and we do NOT appreciate our freedoms that have been fought for by "the Fathers of our Country"....all races of "our Fathers" and "Mothers"!!!
Trumps "placeholders" for powerful positions have rightfully NOT been approved ! We as a nation have never been more vulnerable.
Yes I agree with you too and have often thought that Jimmy Carter was one of the best examples of a Christian that I know of. While I don't identify as Christian myself I do know that Christ was the Prince of Peace. And that's exactly how he lived his life, as President Carter and as citizen Carter, constantly working for Peace, Love and Understanding in this world.
May there be more like him and a role model to look up to in these uncertain times.
Thanks Horhai, I identify as a non-theist, but I respect other people's right to believe as they choose so long as they don't try to enforce their beliefs on me. I do think the man, Jesus of Nazareth was a great orator, and a person of parallel to Jimmy Carter, in other words a truly good human being. I do wish we had more Jesus and Jimmy Carter's than trump's, putin's, musk's, and similar creeps. But as long as people worship wealth over kindness - it ain't gonna happen.
So who are we going to run in 2018?
Thats something we need to start focusing on.
What we really need is to GET OUT THE VOTE.
I admit to being rather suspicious about the election, but unlike MAGA, I won't rant. I keep hearing Trump tell Johnson they "have a little secret" and wonder what that was. Trump never said what it was, but he also can't keep his mouth shut.
Me too, Fay, me too. Agree 100%
Thanks Barbara
Biden can carry forward Carter’s work on the ERA and direct the archivist to publish it, since it is fully ratified as of 2020. Let the litigation continue after it’s published! I’d love to see the “originalists” contort themselves to deny its validity when it has met the requirements plainly stated in the Constitution.
🤞I am hoping & holding my breath as the days whittle away that this will come to pass….not sure what the possibility is or is not as, as far as I can tell, there is NO indication as to where the chips may fall on this.
We know Barbara, we know. 🫤
Thank you for writing perhaps the most historically important essay of yours I’ve ever read. I say that because it describes a north star that guided Jimmy Carter‘s life although someone would say he was guided by Jesus Christ. I prefer north star because it’s a term sometimes associated with sailors And he was in the Navy. The north star of his values and of how he acted on those values to make the world a better place, including attempting to do so while president (although he was thwarted by political forces he could not control) should in a perfect world guide every politician in America… or at least every member of the Democratic Party. And so, while I marvel at the example of a good life so many spoke of, I am in pain because I know following that example will not happen except in the margins in the years ahead. Unless the Democratic Party breaks with the big money interests that Carter himself hated (Citizens United 😡), it will never direct its energies to defeating the evil that exists in society today (Putin, Trump, Musk Alito, et al) by offering the American people the transformational, sustainable development based future that’s out the waiting to be born…. which Carter knew existed.
Robert Reich wrote about Jimmy's take on the American oligarchy.
https://robertreich.substack.com/p/what-jimmy-carter-said-about-the
Yes.
Thank you for the link
I was heartened by the emphasis that was placed on the 39th President's achievements while in office. Too often we've heard about how great he was after his term was over.
If Jimmy Carter taught us anything, it was that we should not dwell on the negativity of our circumstances but, instead, going forward, to keep our eye on the goals we want to achieve for our country.
The Southern Democrats were still transitioning from being racist, misogynistic and xenophobic to being Republicans. Today, the Democrats would have embraced him like they did with Obama.
I've been thinking lately that if Kamala Harris had won the presidential election,,President Carter would have lived at least four more years with a picture of a smiling Rosalyn close by.
I have sadness that he didn’t live to see Harris/Walz win as he had voted for….I think it might have given him a sparkle of content & hope to take with him into whatever comes after. Then, not so nice, another thought occurred to me that he might hang out for awhile in the White House and monitor and whisper in TFFFG’s ear…helping him (as would be his way) or making him cray-cray (as my nasty woman vibe instructs)!
Barbara, about an hour ago I posted a comment here saying that if Kamala had won the election, Carter would have lived another four years with a picture of Rosalyn smiling close by.
Thank you Heather for such a great synopsis of the service today which honored the life of former president Jimmy Carter. As I listened to both Mondale's son and Ford's son share the eulogies their fathers had written YEARS AGO--I couldn't help but realize it was a complete and accurate indictment on Trump (and his supporters) as though it was written today!
Each time I read an article or watch a story of Carter I learn more and more how truly forward thinking and visionary he was. I had not realized his quest to elevate women to positions of power and authority--VERY Jesus like actually :) His early awareness of the effects of climate change, etc...he was truly a MUCH better man than what he was recognized for by our press and fellow politicians. Glad to have been educated!