573 Comments

Good riddance 2020. Good riddance Donald Trump. The best thing of 2020 was discovering Heather Cox Richardson! Your daily affirmations have created it's own movement, it's own energy. And for that we are a grateful nation.

Seventy-five years of economic well-being has lulled Americans into thinking that we were something special, ordained by some almighty being to lead the world. People began to distrust government and why not whens the goings are easy?

No one appreciates what government does until the "Shit hits the fan." Then they clamor for the government to do something. Well, forty years of Movement Conservatives "Starving the Beast" has hamstrung the ability of our leaders to address the serious issues facing us. Couple that with the 2016 election of the most incompetent, most ill-prepared, and most unscrupulous man ever to occupy the White House, and you have the mega-shitstorm of the century.

It's time for a new movement. A movement founded on the common good, decency, and respect for one another. And sometimes the catalyst for that movement is someone you never expected, like a middle-aged, mother of three, from Maine, who took the time to bang out 1200 words: EVERY DAMN NIGHT! A person who teaches you something EVERYDAY!

Here's to better 2021. Here's to a better America. Here's to Dani. And...here's to HCR!

Expand full comment

I can't express how grateful I am for HCR. Heather's posts are the first thing I do or read before getting out of bed every morning. I have learned so much. My sincerest thank you.

Now, how come people aren't calling Trump's actions a treasonist coup on our democracy?

I wish everyone a Happy Healthy New Year! I know 2020 was a lot to bare with all it's craziness and life changing challenges. 2021 will be a rough start but I'm hoping it will bring us strength and courage and the light at the end of trumps terrorist regime gets brighter. President Biden will bring calm and decency back but I question if that even matters to the conservatives.

Expand full comment

The well-being didn't hit everyone. The average income of most Americans has held steady or declined during this period. We still have too many homeless, too many needing food stamps and welfare and too much ignorance being propagated.

Expand full comment

Herb, your post is spot on. Thank you.

Expand full comment

Thanks. Yesterday someone asked to reflect on 2020 and give the most positive thing that happened. My answer was short: HCR

Expand full comment

A few belated thoughts after a rereading HCR’s letter (and some of the comments to it) at the end of 2020.

Am I alone in remembering that the Dems also romanced corporate power and the financial sector? I seem to remember a number of election years in which I was decidedly uneasy (even within the Democratic Party) about fiscal allegiance to these sectors over the needs of the electorate. And those fears proved,to me at least, to be well warranted. Hence I believe that campaign spending must be regulated as the gigantic industry it has become. Or perhaps the genie is already out of the bottle and it is too late to be reversed? As politicians do what they must to survive and stay relevant our democracy has moved by subjugated fits and spurts, if at all. However the swift movement in 2021 of POTUS Biden towards solving current pressing issues fills me with hope.

Expand full comment

I believe you are referring to the Clinton years.

I remember reading an article in -- I believe -- Rolling Stone talking about the political parties, and they noted that unions started to decline in the 1970's, due to the massive inflation, rising interest rates to try to combat inflation, and the general decline of the manufacturing industry as a result. Then Reagan came along, and took a bludgeon to them.

Since the 1930's, the Democratic Party had depended on the unions for campaign funds. No unions, no funds. So they kept losing elections, until Reaganism collapsed under its own self-contradictions, corruption, and incompetence, leading to the "It's the economy, stupid!" line from Clinton at a televised town hall during his campaign against George H.W. Bush.

The Clintons embraced something they called "The third way," which was (basically) capitalism with a heart. Which is a flat-out contradiction-in-terms. What it REALLY seems to have been was a way to pretend to be "socially conscious" while cozying up to the financial and other oligarchs, to replace the source of funding that went away with the unions. Which effectively made them beholden to the same people the Republicans were beholden to.

Expand full comment

Perfect Herb. Thank You!!!!😊💖

Expand full comment

In a year+ of outstanding letters, this one is brilliant! Simply brilliant!

As we begin 2021, I am profoundly grateful for you, HCR. Your calm voice of reason, keen eye for important details and vast knowledge of our political history has given us all a much broader perspective in a year when we could have been buried in the muck and mire that has been 2020. When I felt hopeless in the face of the myriad of woes descending on our country, I hear your calm voice saying "Wait, we've been here before and this is what happened..." Your sleepless nights have not been for naught. There has been a new awakening to the need to be involved in our government and political process. We need to take up oxygen, as you say. Use our voices but also speak with our vote!

Wishing HCR and everyone on this wonderful community a Happy New Year.

Expand full comment

I agree! Seeing where we are in the context of where we have been is enlightening and it helps makes sense of what has felt impossible to understand. I am taking interest in, and learning about, our history in a meaningful way, for the first time. I have heard the term and the idea that we are in line for the American Revolution 2.0. I hope so and I hope it can be as peaceful as possible. Today’s “Letter” gave me chills.

Expand full comment

I second this. You perfectly expressed exactly how I feel about these letters, and about the community Dr. Richardson and we have built.

Expand full comment

yes! this! "There has been a new awakening to the need to be involved in our government and political process. We need to take up oxygen, as you say. Use our voices but also speak with our vote!"

Expand full comment

Great comment, Sally...especially, I, too, know her efforts have not fallen on deaf ears.

Expand full comment

So well said! Thank you Sally ArDubbs

Expand full comment

Totally agree!!

Expand full comment

This is a masterful and astonishing piece of written history, the former because you have tied, piece by piece, very nearly all the plot points of the last 20 (and indeed 40) years of life in America and some parts of the rest of the world (I am especially appreciative of your naming the Republican effort to 'democratize' the world by military might). The piece astonished because it is so very revealing of daily life and ordinary grasp of ways we could see and recognize the malevolent face of Movement Conservatives, and their slippery promises of greatness we could all feel were not only lies but utterly unjust,, without being able to reach and name the racist, sexist roots of the cries of 'socialism'. And what delight to see how Harry Potter fits in (but have you read the Earthsea books by American writer Le Guin, which preceded Rowling's work by decades and say more, better? Take a vacation and treat yourself to the first 4). My last comment is for the way you opened a long, deep, genuinely communal conversation about our civic and personal lives on your thread, and then listened as everyone spoke, gathering all of us into focus to learn from ourselves, each other, you, and our history. "Oh, wonderful, wonderful and still more wonderful!!" From your articulation here of being American, I take hope for the new year ahead. So, thank you. Thank you.

Expand full comment

"...you opened a long, deep, genuinely communal conversation about our civic and personal lives on your thread, and then listened as everyone spoke, gathering all of us into focus to learn from ourselves, each other, you, and our history."

Yes, Heather has a genius for gathering information from many sources and creating concise explications.

Expand full comment

Charlotte! Your comment brings everything full circle for me. Thanks!

Expand full comment

Isn't it relief of heart, mind and conscience to be in conversation about deep, true and daily experiences without feeling pinched of mind and defensive of personal responsibility? Ahhh!

Expand full comment

Wow, Charlotte, that was perfectly said. Thank you for putting into words what was rattling around in my head, and I imagine in the heads of many of us. Bravo!

Expand full comment

I realize I should have added antisemitism to the list above. The virulence of that terrorism is rising again and should not be ignored as we go into the new year.

Expand full comment

Heather Cox Richardson, you are simply brilliant, and today's article is a piece de resistance. When we feel lost in the woods you hand us a map, point, and say: "You are here."

I am beyond grateful for your deep understanding of history and your resolute commitment that this democracy, flawed though it is, not be destroyed. You awaken our better—and fiercer—angels to call forth a better future for us all.

Deep bows of gratitude to you.

Expand full comment

this is totally off the deep end Patricia, but did you happen to grow up in Genoa? I'm looking for a classmate. :D I do agree with your comment here!

Expand full comment

No, I didn't. But I hope you find your friend!

Expand full comment

Perfectly said, Patricia!

Expand full comment

This letter recaps the analysis you presented in your book, "How the South Won the Civil War," but is no less accurate and timely. I hope that we as a nation will be able to recover from the unmitigated disaster of the Trump Administration and the Republican power machine. One thing left out, but no less important, has been the diminished emphasis on the value of basic education, particularly in the abilities to read and think critically and write cogently. A read of the comments (mainly by those supporting Trumpist and radically conservative positions) on any online news article clearly show that America has "dumbed down" to a shocking extent. We need more emphasis on basic education and critical thinking skills to survive the next 20 years.

Expand full comment

30 years ago, my dad, retired USAF, started teaching high school as a substitute teacher. He was shocked by what he called, "the dumbing of Amerca". He was worried then about the implications and foreseeable trajectory of our nation, with "freedumb" citizens and voters.

Here we are dad. RIP

Expand full comment

Freedumb. Oh yes. Saw it too in my brief teaching career 40 years ago.

Expand full comment

As long as politicians dictate what is taught in schools, it’s going to be a downward slide. I see hope in my own kids generation late 20s. They work to be informed and be involved. During the election, teachers were told students were allowed the freedom to express their opinions, but teachers were not to talk about the election. My friend a current events teacher at the high school was not allowed to talk about BLM or any other information from the current news. We seem to need separation of government and schools!

Expand full comment

Educators get censored yet preachers have zero accountability. Huh?

Expand full comment

Absolutely!

Expand full comment

Exactly

Expand full comment

Once again many thanks Heather for your excellent analysis of the last 20 years and the context created in the second half of the 20th Century. Biden's work now, Georgia permitting, is to make sure it doesn't happen again and recover the ground lost. The noxious GOP/Koch etc ideology will persist. If government of the people for the people by the people is to survive and thrive, the people must take it back in hand, keep it in hand and elect only those that will do the people's will and work for the general good of everybody regardless of colour, sex, or race....including the economically innovative and successfull.

Expand full comment

It took decades for us to get to where we are and it will take decades to rectify our broken nation. Heather has provided the gift of education to recognize what has transpired. It really is up to “we the people” to use that knowledge to make the necessary changes to redirect this diversely rich country.

That process requires us to continue to educate ourselves and our children, stay engaged, pay attention, speak up and out, and actively participate. Even on the local level (as I found out!) politics can be a full contact sport! Not being a politician, I was totally blindsided by the vitriol and nastiness when the “old boys network” was questioned. I was also told (afterwards) a woman “at the head of the table” did not rest well with them! To “soothe” my battered psyche, my husband would read from some colonial newspapers the battles between Adams and Jefferson (i.e. some things haven’t changed) ...it didn’t help!

We must never lose our voices and we must continue to make those voices heard.

John Lewis- “get in good trouble, necessary trouble” - a motto we all should embrace and live by!

Expand full comment

Not to be Pollyanna, but I see this "opportunity" we are in to evolve rapidly. This recent and more transparent coup on our democracy by American and global oligarchs is cruel and deadly we can no longer ignore their atrocities. (Well, we can, but we shan't hopefully). I have felt it like we have been forced into an evolutional ratcheting backwards by the dying, white patriarchy. And I am of a hopeful view that with our reason and knowledge, our ability to communicate and to coalesce we will ratchet forward rather rapidly because, I think , we have the Will to change our endangered world. Like that wonderful letter from the principal above, we do have to see the whole of our world very differently. Perhaps that is the biggest gift of the pain and losses during this "so-called" presidency and pandemic is our ability of like-minds for the benefit of all to come together to right this ship in a very new, very rapid way.

Some of Heather's Herd are going to meet virtually via Zoom on a Sunday--the date and time is being set so friends around the world can join at a convenient time. It would be lovely if Heather could join us!! It is looking like this Saturday, possibly 1:00 EST. Contact heathersherd@gmail.com to confirm and receive a Zoom invitation. We should know the exact time today and can post.

(I broke my two week writing abstinence vacation. I so highly respect and admire Heather and the people she has drawn to this forum. Thank you for helping me to enter the new year with a lot more hope and sense of purpose with fellow travelers).

Expand full comment

I applaud you getting involved politically on the local level. It is not for the faint of heart and it is true service and sacrifice, for those who are there for the right reasons.

Expand full comment

Thanks Pamsy. The nastiness of local politics can be particularly stinging because the people are your neighbors. After years of observation (I also served on other boards and was active in schools and tax overrides) there were a couple of events that finally catapulted me to running and being elected to the (all volunteer) leadership board ... I went in with eyes wide open, but very naive to the realities. In a letter I wrote at the end of my term, I noted that the threats and vile behavior towards me were tactics that keep good people from serving. My “crimes” included pushing for meeting and town committee transparency and, the horror of all horrors, accuracy in recording meeting minutes (which at times were needed for legal purposes). I was an advocate for open government at all levels. For that, I was accused of overstepping and “micro-managing” (along with some unprintable terms!) and there was an attempt to recall me (which did not work - I had tremendous support from the community). I’m obviously still not over it, but I just might be incentivized now to finish my book/blog (names changed to protect the guilty of course) as therapy! 😂

Expand full comment

Too bad it is necessary to protect the guilty, but for sure they would slam you. Maybe consult with a lawyer beforehand. And maybe later an anonymous post - not by you of course - could provide a key to identities.

Expand full comment

Years have gone by and some of the culprits are deceased so a modified “fictionalized” version could work to avoid any legal problems. The Town’s attorney also guided me during that time period (pro bono).

Expand full comment

Still it would, I think, require moxie on your part, for which I, who risk nothing like you do, salute you.

Expand full comment

One thing about aging is the gained confidence that I really could have used in my younger years!

Expand full comment

Thanks for your insights as well...let's all make necessary trouble as loudly as needed.

Expand full comment

'We must never lose our voices and we must continue to make those voices heard.'

Indeed, over the course of the posts I read from HCR, the books I have bought and am reading - for the first time - on political and social history and perspective - and my observation of the hype/rise and fall of the news cycles - my main concern is consistent and persistent engagement with the political tides of the times going forward. Now that many of us have been shook awake again to the machinations of the machines that have overtaken so much of our political process (frankly, on both sides of the fence), we must stand sentinel to our views and beliefs as well as continue participation in the political process. I will be teaching that to my daughter as she grows into adulthood. It is going to be her and her cohorts that need to continue to engage and advocate for their beliefs without being subsumed yet again by those focused mainly on personal power and financial gain. The current generation of young adults has started the work to be engaged, and work as activists for their viewpoints, and it will need to continue to keep the focus on the democratic ideals that found our nation.

Expand full comment

Words fail me. You have started every day with me and given me hope - for that I am eternally grateful and look to 2021 with HOPE.

Wishing I could give you a hug of thanks. I hope we don’t forget how to hug our families, friends, neighbors and strangers when we have this pandemic under control.

Expand full comment

I ponder the difference between our national experience and what happened in Sweden starting in the time between the two world wars ... the formation of the amazing and long lasting relationship between the Social Democrats (the government of the people and by the people), the Swedish Trade Union Confederation (the labor union movement which included agrarian support), and the Swedish Employers Association (the financial "elite"). The Employers Association was incredibly remarkable, having at its core fewer than 20 families, with the standout family being the Wallenbergs (industrialist bankers who at one time owned companies employing 20% of the Swedish workforce).

The collaboration among these three forces, the Social Democratic government, the labor unions, and the company ownership would then collaborate over the following decades to create a highly egalitarian society that evolved over time as society changed and ideals changed to include the rights of women, child care, health care, education, etc.

The interesting image that comes to my mind from our nation between the two world wars is the image of Henry Ford being carried in his chair from his office by members of the National Guard because he was locking out workers attempting to form a union ... the opposite of the Swedish Employers Association and the Wallenberg family in particular.

Sweden and the Nordic countries owe much to the Wallenberg family for the leadership in helping to establish a different society than accomplished by the bloody Russian Revolution or the slower but similarly bloody Nazi Revolution in Germany.

At this time, FDR was forming the basis for the prospect of a similar society in our nation ... but as you point out, there has always been the American West image to appeal to ... if you don't like life where you are, then rather than work together to build a better society, you simply move west and take over land occupied by Native Americans, killing them if it suits your purpose, and create your own vision of life.

I grew up in a rural environment prior to the time of Reagan and farm cooperatives were common to serve business needs of the community ranging from farm supplies, mutual insurance companies, and financial needs. With the shrinking of the small farms and the growth of large farms, farm cooperatives have faded ... and they represented a social democratic aspect of society, of people working together as opposed to being "rugged individuals".

At the time Reagan was elected, I remember a feeling of horror regarding what was happening to our nation ... and that horror has only grown over the past 40 years.

We need some of the wisdom and generosity of the Wallenberg family to exist in our "elite" ... and it is difficult to find. Meanwhile, we have a large portion of the nation that thanks in part to the ending of the Fairness Doctrine can view society from their echo chamber and express rage without any intelligent understanding of working together as a society.

The next years will be an interesting challenge ... will we really continue to have a government of the people, by the people, and for the people ... will we be able to examine what the Nordic countries are doing and learn what could benefit our society as well as learn from their challenges?

Expand full comment

Thank you for sharing this perspective. The Wallenberg family seems to have set an example of true leadership by privileged elites in partnership with government and unions... for the benefit of all. We can undoubtedly learn from studying this model.

Expand full comment

Wonderful post. Not that they meet my definition of elite, but could you imagine the Trump family or better, Bezos with his million employers, taking on a role comparable to the Wallenbergs?

Expand full comment

A terrific, clear-eyed analysis. Thank you, thank you - and best wishes for 2021.

I am a dual UK /US national, and whenever in the US, am impressed by the "patriotism", or what I would call "jingoism", embedded in American life. Flags on the lawn and everywhere else is a minor expression. Almost every single TV advertisement contains either a flag, or the word "America" as in "America's favorite.." (check next time you watch TV - you may not have noticed) National anthems at sporting events (we reserve that for international competition). Oaths of allegiance in *schools*, for Goodness sake. Nowhere in Europe would (or could) this happen. This is, to my mind, insidious brainwashing and surely a large component of the polarization currently being experienced. The old Soviet Union did exactly the same thing, as does China now. This has become more and more prevalent since Reagan, I believe. I don't remember politicians wearing flag lapel pins, for example, until the 70's when Republican candidates wore them as an expression of their patriotism. Obama had a major problem with this, and didn't want to wear one, but eventually succumbed, as it was deemed "unpatriotic" Just sayin'...

Expand full comment

Thank you for your perspective, Constantine. I am always interested in hearing what people from other countries think about America and American life. I think we hear far too little of this, which leaves us in a national “echo chamber”.

Expand full comment

Constantine, this is just what my husband has pointed out to me. He is also a dual UK/US national.

Expand full comment

So many of our "systems need to be re-designed at the same time. From education that teaches critical thinking and integrity to tv and media that appears to dumb us down or even brainwash alternative realities. What are we teaching and producing for the next generations?

Expand full comment

I am also a dual US/UK citizen who moved to the UK 14 years ago. Yes to what you've said. I wish more Americans spent at least a year or two abroad, preferably early in life (and not in the military, which brings its own culture with it), to truly develop a broader perspective.

Expand full comment

From a year of letters weaving the history of American politics into today’s reality, you have been amazing. This one is the most succinct for me. Wowed. Thank you and sincere wishes for a brighter 2021 for us all.

Expand full comment

The importance of an overview from 50,000 feet cannot be stressed enough. It enables us to "see" the long-view strategy that the GOP has assiduously executed (while we were distracted by so many other things and struggles in our everyday lives) to create for themselves an authoritarian government in which they would "rule" and extract enormous wealth from the labors and taxes of the commoners. HCR, YOU NAILED IT, and we are grateful!

Expand full comment

P.S. This substantiates a belief I have always held -- and stated many times -- but was unable to back up with examples and evidence so as to convince anyone: That the GOP has been playing the long game to completely undo FDR's new deal and Johnson's Great Society.

And now, here we are, standing on thin ice, as the GOP continues to obstruct and disrupt and undermine Biden before he even takes the oath of office.

Expand full comment

To this excellent analysis, which shows deep understanding of recent American history, I would add only one idea: the assassinations of John F. Kennedy, Martin Luther King and Robert F. Kennedy robbing the progressive side of our politics and government of brilliant, compassionate leaders who possessed the ability to explain Democratic, anti-poverty positions that might have changed the political calculus.

Expand full comment

Who benefited from these assassinations?

Expand full comment

i am very grateful for the nyt article which led me to you. I dont understand how you write these incredibly nuanced, thoughtful pieces every day. Bravo and thank you. You are the ultimate dot connector. As for your readers, we all need to help build your reach. Every day, let's all forward the email to five new people. Thank you Heather, from your newest fan on Marthas Vineyard.

Expand full comment

THANK YOU Dr. Richardson! Thank you for articulating the trajectory of the conservative movement of the last 40 years. It's actually exhilarating to see this laid out so cogently. I was in my early teens when Reagan was elected, and have known in my bones since then that he was the front man for an ideology that I consider inherently unfair and even dangerous to our democracy. I thought the 80's were a horror show politically, and things have gone down hill since then for the most part. Even when Democrats do gain power, Republicans have become so nasty and effective at blocking them that my frustration just grows, to say nothing of the corporate takeover of the dems as well. I really appreciate your analyses of why we got here, and this community of people who understand and acknowledge these problems. The women AND the men ;-)

Thank you.

Expand full comment

This time of yr always calls for a looking back. Most times we look at what happened in the last yr as we prepare for a New Year. There is no question the last yr has been horrific, some would say the last 4 yrs has been beyond awful (me!)...what have we done to ourselves, what is wrong with this country & its leaders. Focusing on this short time frame for what a future holds for us conjures despair BUT widening our past view 20 yrs, as you have done in this beautifully written historical perspective, that moral arc of the universe shows us the bend toward justice, equality, fairness, progressive thinking is surely bending, slowly being realized & addressed where it needs to be through citizen activism, government policy & laws. This “20 year in review” has helped my perspective moving forward. My commitment to remaining active in preserving democracy & supporting progressive, empathetic leadership is stronger than ever. Let’s allow ourselves a small moment of celebration for our future as we continue to fight this pandemic. History always shows us how we can shape our future. We just need to know & understand that history...so thank you HCR & the other voices of history. Be well!

Expand full comment