780 Comments
⭠ Return to thread

Lessons from Lincoln. History reminds us of so much if we just pay attention. Thank you Professor ⭐

Expand full comment

This line is the one that spoke to me most: "A public practice of ignoring the law eventually broke down all the guardrails designed to protect individuals, while lawbreakers, going unpunished, became convinced they were entitled to act without restraint." We are witnessing this in spades right now, though here's hoping the E. Jean Carroll case is the start of an avalanche of judgments reversing the trend. Still, I wish the law/DOJ and the courts could work with more alacrity. I fear American democracy is running out of time.

Expand full comment

Jude, have heart! New York DA starts Trump's criminal trial in 36 days! This is a strong case, the co-defendant who was less culpable (Michael Cohen) did jail time. Manhattan juries have not been real impressed with Trump these days! Yeah Georgia case is far off, Aileen 'Loose' Cannon will give Trump endless delays in Florida and despite best efforts of Jack Smith to get his case to trial, appeals are likely to delay the D.C. federal case to an unknowable date. BUT 'have no fear, Alvin Bragg is near, his determination is clear, Trump will go to jail for over a year'! https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/25/nyregion/trump-hush-money-trial-stormy-daniels.html?unlocked_article_code=1.RE0.tCM7.-iuQz_raEOVH&smid=url-share

Expand full comment

100Panthers, is it mean of me to be gleeful that TFFG will not have access to hairspray or bronzer in jail? Have no idea if his cult will respond “whoa, yuk!” to pics of him w/o his coiffure and tan slather…you know, just a regular jamoke behind bars….deflated.

Expand full comment

Jail for Trump means no burgers, no french fries, no milk shakes, and no hookers. As this realization sinks in, watch his level of anxiety and hysteria skyrocket.

Expand full comment

No hookers, no Sharpies, no power.

Expand full comment

James Burnham, and no ketchup!

Expand full comment

No endless supply of adderall. No social media. And maybe a work assignment?

Expand full comment

lol ! Isn't it grand though to see 100Panthers upbeat enough to be inspired to 4 lines of rhyme ?

Expand full comment

Hi Barbara, There are so many things to add to what you just said. But, I will be banned for life from this site. It's killing me. 🤭

Expand full comment

Hmmm Barbara, good question. I'm thinking, given the constant surveillance and video, might be sort of 'charming' to let his followers watch him primp like a vain little teenage girl for a few hours and then just sit in his cell all day doing nothing but whining like a cat in heat...only to repeat the process the next day. Riker's Island, got my tan at a vacation spot in The Islands!

Expand full comment

1000Panthers, I seem to recall a while ago another commenter posting something about a new reality show called the Prison Apprentice….with you know who starring. Well, I never watched the first one, but might consider peeking at an episode or two of the Prison Apprentice!

Expand full comment

Oh glory!

Expand full comment

Damn! My gasp at your comment made the coffee go down the wrong way! Thx for the chuckle!

Expand full comment

DA - ALVIN L BRAGG is already writing a script for "Prison Apprentice", ... well, the opening scenes anyway.

Here is Alvin's 1st Draft:

Trump; "So have you heard of me Alvin?

Alvin: Yes.

Trump: "What did you hear Shane" ... 'er Alvin.

Alvin: "I heard You are a low-down Yankee LIAR"

Trump; "Eh, prove It!"

Hat tip to Jack Palance & Alan Ladd.

" ... Come back Shane".

Expand full comment

Criminal proceedings may not be enough to stop him. Hitler wrote Mein Kampf in prison.

Expand full comment

Talia, do they sell Sharpies by the truckload? Can’t imagine him writing anything other than his signature or a tweet (X).

Expand full comment

But plenty of smart people do his dirty work for him. It’s why he’s still in the news…

Expand full comment

it doesn't have to have coherent logic or substance (Mein K sure as shine-ola didn't). the lunatic tools and cynical enablers would be the next to look out for.

Expand full comment

er, WATCH out for, i should have said

Expand full comment

Good point. The Georgia and 2 federal cases are trailing, as are investigations in other states, he should get swamped. Only if society loses its nerve and lets him off the hook as did Germany, Cuba etc. But those protagonists were much younger and healthier.

Expand full comment

But Trump needs a ghostwriter.

Expand full comment

He has more than a few, Stephen Miller at top of list.

Expand full comment

Is Miller even human?

Expand full comment

And Lincoln’s message? it’s up to all of us, together, to carry the day: For starters, vote & support grass roots organizations. There are so many ways.

Expand full comment

"of the people, by the people, for the people", for real.

Expand full comment

Thank you for the link to the New York Times story of January 25. As is usual nowadays, they are a day late and a dollar short on this story. When NY DA Alvin Bragg first filed the charges, he told America it was an election interference case. Clean and simple. Bragg could see the writing on the wall for shallow media, that they would defang it into a hush-money case about prostitution. He is not now "rebranding" the charges; he is reiterating the original framework for criminally charging Donald Trump. I find the New York Times insufferable in its intentional low-level coverage of Trump's many case. They continue to normalize Trump's heinous behavior.

Expand full comment

Cancel your subscription like I did! I miss reading some of the columnists, still though I refuse to support thier practice.

Expand full comment

I did 2 years ago. I see their free daily round-up.

Expand full comment

100, thanks for the laugh of the day!

Expand full comment

That paragraph stood out for me also.

Expand full comment

Remarkable speech that still speaks to us today! Thank you for teaching us history through the speeches of our heroes!

Expand full comment

It still galls be every time I think about the fact that, with little public comment, so far as I could tell, the Lincoln's Birthday holiday was tossed into the black hole of "President's Day.

Lincoln was not only key actor in American society's evolution toward greater awareness and justice, he was a particularly articulate "explainer" of what a just republic is all about. You can't adequately manage what you don't adequately understand, and Lincoln still provides a useful guide.

Expand full comment

I remember when each "major" president got a day to celebrate. Then somebody decided the nation had to lump them all together into one day. Hated it, and still do.

Expand full comment

Agreed, and good morning, Lynell.

I have a theory about Presidents Day: There was a long, long slog through the winter from New Years Day to Easter or Spring Break. The decision was made (while I was in college, so late 70's I believe) to have a Federal Holiday on the Monday between Feb 12th (Lincoln) and Feb 22nd (Washington).

Expand full comment

My recollection is a bit different; when the movement to commemorate Dr. King gathered momentum, there was opposition to establishing another federal holiday, so the two February Presidential birthdays were consolidated, and Dr. King got a day that occasionally actually coincides with his birthday.

Expand full comment

I remember it your way as well, Dave.

Expand full comment

Dave, neither holiday was established without a lot of conflict. At the federal level, President's Day was established in 1971 and MLK day was established in 1983. The two things I know is that I had my first school holiday in Oregon in 1978 and that Virginia likes to call MLK day "Robert E. Lee" day.

Expand full comment

Yes, that, too. I grew up down South, and we didn't even acknowledge Lincoln's birthday, for reasons now too obvious.

Expand full comment

Feb 12, if memory serves

Expand full comment

It does. February 12, 1809.

Expand full comment

A big deal, even in NC when I was a pup

Expand full comment

Indeed.

I'm reading "Fever in the Heartland", and amidst the horror of just how long we've been this way as a country, I recalled that even the terrible, reactionary Supreme Court they had back in the 20s eventually changed to the better court we had in the 70s, and it was very calming to remember that.

It feels quite often like we're going one step forward, two steps back, but perhaps we're really going two steps forward, one step back, and gradually making progress.

I sure hope so.

Expand full comment

Rebecca Solnit expresses such themes in Hope in the Dark. There's more progress than the dominant groups want people to realize. "The arc of the moral universe..."

Expand full comment

slow but sure as long as we do not despair and give up. Keep moving

Expand full comment

Pat, as have posted here numerous times….the anthem to keep my juice from flagging is Jackson Browne’s Til I Go Down (and you can dance to it!): (ad may play first) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bmzimxfqgfw

Expand full comment

We continue to make "progress" in a number of ways, but are running out of time in others. We have got to do a number of things differently.

Expand full comment

"Fever in the Heartland" - great, horrifying book.

Expand full comment

Haven't dared to read it, and I now regret putting "Hope in the Dark" on my Kindle where good books go to die. Just starting "True West", about the myths that gave rise to resistance to law and order.

Expand full comment

Oh, I love my Kindle! Thanks a million for the other recs. True West sounds totally up my alley.

Expand full comment

My paperback came yesterday, and the type is pretty small, so I may regret not ordering the Kindle version. But it has end notes and an index like good nonfiction used to.

Expand full comment

You're talking about the book by Betsy Gaines, right? (This is reminding me of the Sam Shepard play, which I love!).

Expand full comment

Karen, looks like there's a time algorithm to SCROTUS. Awful in the 20's, but came to life in the 50's under the Warren Court, and continued through the 70's. Hopefully, it will swing back before 2250...

Expand full comment

And remind all that once upon a time the republican party claimed to be the party of Lincoln. Seems it’s not that Lincoln or it’s not this Republican Party.

Expand full comment

No, the republican party was taken over by the Freedom party.

Expand full comment

Free-dumb, don't you mean?

Expand full comment

More accurately called the "Chaos Caucus."

Expand full comment

Now, the Republican party has been destructed as the party of DJT. I wonder what the new Party of Lincoln will call itself? The Legions of Law and Lincoln...? I am sure there are many better ideas out there...

Expand full comment

Every time Heather writes about Lincoln, I’m amazed at his profound insights, and how enormously relevant they still are!

Expand full comment

Not to mention how young he was when he laid them out.

Expand full comment

Exactly. I felt like I was only halfway through my puberty at that age... :/

Expand full comment

Lincoln had a way of getting right to the point.

“There are a thousand hacking at the branches of evil to one who is striking at the root.”

- Thoreau

Expand full comment

Yes he did JL; and as Bryan adequately postulates "Lincoln's deductive reasoning was already well developed.." , as was his ability to identify as opposed to comparing, empathy and emotional, cultural I.Q.

Expand full comment

Thank you SLR Lucky Chix. I do not recall reading an Abraham Lincoln from his younger development years. Lincoln's deductive reasoning was already well developed, "gates of hell shall not prevail against" ... a "greater institution."

No wonder Lincoln found General Grant. Hat Tip to Paul Krugman -- something of a Grant historian.

Expand full comment